The Liberty is a beautiful ship, so bright, colorful and cheery. The crew were amazing, they were good at what they do. We got greeted so friendly right from stepping out of the taxi at the pier. I love the layout of the ship, just had a few problems with getting lost now and then but that makes it fun. The atrium was decorated beautifully for Christmas with garland, lights and trees. Our room stewards were awesome, our head steward was Rgo and he was great, we kept forgetting our room number and whenever he saw us would laugh and say 1324 and point us in right direction. Our room was always cleaned and the towel animals were very nice every night. Our dining room waiter Jorge was great, so attentive and funny. Butch the Cruise Director was fantastic, he sure knows how to get a crowd going and in the mood to have fun. He even pulled our daughter up on stage one night it was hilarious. The food in the dining room was excellent. The only thing we were a little displeased with was the dinner buffet in Emilos. We felt there should have been more staples in the evening for dinner like meats, potatoes, veggies etc not just the theme night foods. One night we never even had dinner because there just was nothing that we fancied on the buffet besides salads and fruit. The grille food was fantastic, burgers, chicken etc. The deli foods were great also. The pizza was not too bad either. My nephews enjoyed the kids clubs. Soon as the clubs started we never saw either of them till dinner time, heck a couple nights my 12 year old nephew was the last one to go to bed. The last night of the cruise my 17 year old nephew didnt come in till 5am he said they had a party and then after it ended all the kids just hung out. Overall the ship is an A in our eyes. We would certainly sail Carnival again.