Even though we are seasoned cruisers, this was our first cruise on an Oasis-class ship, Allure of the Seas, and she is majestic: enormous, gorgeous and oh-so impressive! The itinerary (Eastern Caribbean) didn't matter much for us, we were mainly drawn by the ship, the date (Memorial Day week) and the ease: only a drive to Port Everglades from Miami (no need to fly, which with young kids who are 1.5 & 3 years old, is always a hassle!). We were blessed with beautiful sunny weather and an ocean-view balcony cabin, so we don't have any complaints... only a brief list of challenges which can be improved (along with suggestions) and a laundry list of things we loved.
OPPORTUNITIES FOR IMPROVEMENT
* Muster Drill: it's never fun, always a hassle, too long/hot/boring, but we know it must be done! Once it concludes, it is literally a stampede with thousands of people rushing back into the air-conditioned ship, to get back to having fun. This is a challenge for families with children on strollers and anyone on a wheelchair... particularly to enter an elevator and not be "sardine-ed" or having to wait for many elevators to come and go before being able to board. Our recommendation if for RCCL to announce and enforce an initial 5 minute period or so, for those with strollers/wheelchairs/walking devices to exit first, allowing them to board elevators, before the mass exodus.
Nice cabin, but the space is very tight, particularly when the sofa bed is made out in the evenings. We kept the balcony door securely locked about 99% of the time (only had a couple of breakfasts when safely docked in ports of call) because of our 2 young children. There is really very little storage space for clothes/shoes/items... so if you pack a lot like we did (inevitable when travelling with a baby), you will likely have to keep a lot of your stuff in your bags throughout the cruise (probably under the bed).
We took a private cab to Orient Beach, where we rented some chairs and a beach umbrella. The beach is lovely, but there might be concerns with the amount of sea-weed and the surf could be considered slightly rough.
Took trams to get to the furthest beach (I think it's called Columbus), where plenty of beach chairs were available (placed under shady palm trees). There was a bar and a food station nearby, as well as quite clean bathrooms... much improved from a decade ago! And the water was clean/calm... great for families to enjoy!
Only boarded and disembarked... the process wasn't bad, but the industrial view of the containers/cranes was certainly not pretty by any means!