We loved the Liberty. Embarkation and debarkation was the best ever! Food in Windjammer was good, as well as the formal dining area. Our servers Magesh and Carlos were fantastic!

Our room steward was wonderful! I left numerous notes for him and fulfilled our request without blinking an eye! The entertainment was good, especially, the broadway show. Don't miss it!! The cleaning crew was always working. The diamond club was exceptional! This was our 23rd cruise, and we enjoyed the club almost every night. We loved the lifeguards! They kept the pool controlled and enjoyable. They were very professional! We had one complaint, there was not sheer curtains on dining room 5. But, 3 and 4 had them. It caused me great discomfort with another cruiser. She wanted the drapes always closed!! Which, was a dis service to me, because after 23 cruises I finally got a beautiful window seat, and wanted to observe the view. She complained the whole time. Our server had to pin the curtains together, which obstructed my view! The curtains kept hitting my hair. This was not fair to me either! But, we noticed, deck 3-4 had sheers, which kept sun out, but still allowed you the option of observing the view. Yuk! Also, don't like how RC is charging for room service!! But, over all it was a good cruise. Will see the Liberty again May 2018. Please don't give us deck 5 dining!