Carnival Magic Review

Magic was more than magical - it was phenomenal!

Review for the Eastern Caribbean Cruise on Carnival Magic
User Avatar
estillcrew
6-10 Cruises • Age 50s

Rating by category

Cabin
Value for Money
Embarkation
Dining
Public Rooms
Entertainment
Fitness & Recreation
Service

Additional details

Sail Date: Mar 2017
Cabin: Spa Balcony

The Carnival Magic was indeed a magical vacation. I can’t begin to fathom the negative reviews I have read about this magnificent ship. We have been on numerous cruises, and this was our favorite ship thus far.

My husband (51), 16 year old daughter, her friend, and I (50) drove to Port Canaveral from Hoover, Alabama after school on Friday, March 24, 2017. We stopped after six hours of driving and spent the night at the Hampton Inn in Lake City, Florida. We love Hampton Inns because of their free full breakfasts and comfortable beds. This Hampton Inn was like all others except it was a little bit noisier since it was close to the interstate. We slept just fine, awoke and got ready, and then went downstairs to make our waffles. While we were eating our breakfast, we ran into three different families who were also headed to Port Canaveral to board the Magic.

After breakfast Saturday morning, we loaded in the car for our three hour trip to Port Canaveral. I wasn’t prepared for all of the toll roads on I-75, so I sure am glad I had plenty of dollar bills! We spent approximately $8 in tolls from Lake City to Port Canaveral. Florida sure is proud of their roads! There was no traffic, and we arrived at the port ten minutes before our check-in time of 12:30-1:00. It took us almost 45 minutes to get parked once we arrived inside the gate. Apparently, they started construction that morning, so they rerouted the Carnival people. It was causing quite the traffic jam and the workers directing traffic were apologizing profusely to everyone. My husband dropped off us and our bags, and then he parked the car. He had no trouble finding a spot in the deck and met us at the entrance to the terminal about 10 minutes later. We were in line at 1:10, so I was a little bit annoyed that it took so long to park when I had read how quickly things ran at Port Canaveral. The check in line was very long, but we had our gold sign and sail cards in hand and were on the boat within 15 minutes of getting in that long line. We couldn’t believe how quickly the line moved and how friendly everyone was at Port Canaveral.

Cabin Review

Spa Balcony

Cabin 8P

My husband and I had room 11240, a balcony room on the spa deck. It was very convenient to the Lido deck, spa, and elevators and was very quiet during the night. The décor of the spa rooms is different from the other balcony rooms, but the bathrooms are exactly the same. The spa rooms are soft tan and green while the other rooms are orange and tan. Our room had the twin beds pushed together for us (per our online check-in request), a coffee table, sofa, two nightstands, a desk and chair, three closets, four drawers, and a refrigerator. We were given complimentary bedroom slippers that said Cloud 9 on them, and the spa robes were hanging in our closet for us to use. We put our two bottles of wine and our two complimentary HUGE bottles of water (VIFP perk) in our refrigerator, and they stayed very cold during our trip. We put magnetic hooks on the walls (thanks cruise critic peeps for the tip) for our purses, hats, and wet bathing suits. We unpacked, slid our suitcases under the bed to get them out of the way. I should mention that the spa cabins have complimentary bottles of spa shampoo, conditioner, lotion, and bar soap in addition to the soap and shampoo dispensers hanging on the shower wall, but those bottled products smelled like marijuana. I swear, they must have had hemp extract in them or something. I was very thankful that the dispensers of soap and shampoo were in the spa cabins so I didn’t smell like I had been smoking reefer with the locals! HA!

Port Reviews

Port Canaveral (Orlando)

This was the quickest port to get in and out of! The employees were very friendly!

Amber Cove (Puerto Plata)

We had never been to the Dominican Republic, so we were anxious for this port. Apparently, Carnival just finishing building this port in 2015, so it is relatively new.We booked the Deluxe Sail and Snorkel excursion with Tip Top Catamaran and had a blast! We got off the ship and found our excursion guy holding our sign. We boarded a bus and drove about 45 minutes to our catamaran. The bus ride was not bad, as we learned lots about the Dominican Republic while we rode. We arrived on the beach and had to be shuttled via a dingy to our catamaran. It took about four trips to get everyone on the catamaran, and then we were off. We literally sailed about 10 minutes and stopped for our first snorkel. There wasn’t much to see and the wind and crazy waves made the water pretty murky. The waves kicked up, so we couldn’t stop at the second snorkel site. There was an open bar with free rum punch and local beer, soft drinks, fruit juice and water, lots of dancing, and a good lunch. The lunch was hard boiled eggs, coleslaw, pasta salad, tuna salad, chicken nuggets, chicken sliders, cucumber salads, bread, ham and pastrami cold cuts, etc. We ate, drank, and danced while we sailed all the way back to port. There was no bus ride on the way back. YAY! It was a fantastic day, and we even had about 45 minutes to shop in port before we had to be back on board.

San Juan

We had been there before and knew there wasn’t much to do. We didn’t get into port until 12:00, so we got to sleep late. I have to tell you that I like arriving into port later. I was hesitant at first, but we got to stay out later, sleep later, and have places to ourselves since the other cruise ships leave port around 4:00. After eating lunch on the ship, we walked to the forts. We took lots of beautiful pictures and sweated a ton. Man, it was hot, but the history is so cool and the views from atop the forts are breathtaking! We found a couple in the square who would let you pose with their four exotic birds for $5. We took lots of great pictures, and the owners posed the birds in many different ways for the pictures. It was something different, and the girls loved it.

Grand Turk

I am so glad that I listened to the advice on Cruise Critic and did not book at excursion. The cruise port there is so very nice. I was worried because our boat was the second one to arrive (we docked at 12:00), so I was afraid that there would not be any loungers available. Boy, was I wrong. We were one of the first families off of the Magic and there were tons of free chairs and umbrellas available. We walked off the dock and turned left to Margaritaville and there were tons of chairs available around the pool and beach. Because the ocean is so pretty, we decided to find chairs on the beach instead. We found a nice spot with four loungers under palm trees in front of the Flo Rider spot. We were very close to the DJ playing the music in Margaritaville, so we could hear great music while we looked at the ocean. There was a local selling cold beer under a red tent for $5 a bottle and 2 cups of rum punch for $5, so that is where we bought our drinks. The same beer in Margaritaville was $8.50 a bottle! We were chilling under the palm trees, and looking at the beautiful ocean when someone came by asking if we wanted to go on a banana boat ride. The girls did, so we paid them $20 a person and walked to their tent. We filled out a permission form, they climbed on the banana boat, and I hopped in the boat with the driver and took some awesome pics of them as they were being pulled around in that crystal clear water. They had a blast and said they wished it had lasted longer, but I was ready to get back to my lounger. After a while, the girls met up with their friends at the pool at Margaritaville and we visited the beer tent again. Heeding the advice of my cruise critic pals, we walked about 5 minutes down the beach to Jack’s Shack for lunch for some of the best jerk chicken I have ever put in my mouth. For $14 a plate, we had jerk chicken and fries (my daughter had rice and beans instead of fries), and we had plenty of it. We had signed up for a free shot of rum on Jack’s Shack website prior to our cruise, and got our free shots after our lunch. After lunch, we played ball with Jack’s dog, Topher, and headed back to our loungers. We passed a place that sold $4 beers, so we grabbed two. They weren’t as cold as the $5 beers, so I wished we had waited until we got back to the guy in the red tent to buy our beers. We had such a fabulous time and stayed on this beach until we had to be back on the boat. We did save about 30 minutes to shop in the stores. We found the best t-shirts here. This was an amazing port with plenty to do just a few yards from the boat. Highly recommend staying here for the day instead of booking an excursion.

20 Helpful Votes
previous reviewnext review

Find a Carnival Magic Cruise from $379

Any Month

Get special cruise deals, expert advice, insider tips and more.By proceeding, you agree to our Privacy Policy and Terms of Use.

© 1995—2024, The Independent Traveler, Inc.