Subscribe today
Get Cruise Critic in your inbox
Your Ultimate Cruise Guide

Carnival Victory Cruise Review by Annes4: Victory was less than a win


Annes4
2 Reviews
Member Since 2009
0 Posts

Member Rating

Cabin 5.0
Dining 4.0
Embarkation 4.0
Enrichment Activities 1.0
Entertainment 2.0
Family & Children Not Rated
Fitness & Recreation 3.0
Public Rooms 5.0
Rates 3.0
Service 4.0
Shore Excursions 3.0
Value for Money 3.0

Compare Prices on Carnival Victory Southern Caribbean Cruises

Victory was less than a win

Sail Date: June 2009
Destination: Southern Caribbean
Embarkation: San Juan

This was my granddaughter's first cruise experience, my seventh.  I thought taking her on a cruise where we could get reaquainted would be a pleasant high school graduation gift to her as we live in cities about 1,000 miles apart and only get to visit a couple times a year.

The check in procedure at the Carnival dock in San Juan, P.R. was very efficient with a minimum of waiting in lines.  The greeting as we boarded the ship, however, was nonexistent.  As an experienced cruise passenger, I had some idea of what to do once on board but I'm sure a first timer would have been totally confused.  Very few crew members were available to answer questions.

Over all, the food was excellent and varied with several options for meals in addition to the two formal dining rooms.  While our wait staff was very slow and inefficient, others we observed were very well prepared and professional so the dining room service was definitely a mixed bag.  On this More cruise, the food was definitely the high point.

The ship appeared to be well maintained and public areas were clean and neat all week and yet the cleaning crews were not intrusive.

The port excursions were numerous and varied but definitely geared toward the younger, physically able passenger.  Even the tours labeled "EASY" were not particularly easy for anyone with the slightest mobility issue.  For one thing, the hired transportation vehicles were difficult to "climb" into and an inexpensive folding step stool would have gone a long way to make access easier and safer for the older passengers.  Excursion costs were reasonable but there weren't very many "extras" included in most of them such as snacks, etc.  The beauty of the islands visited seemed to increase as the cruise progressed.

Unfortunately, the on-board entertainment and amusements were mediocre at best and at many times, non-existent.  While activities were listed on the ship's daily newsletter, often they did not occur.  The camaraderie I have experienced on other cruises was not at all present on this one.  Other than at evening activities, the Cruise Director's staff was noticeably missing.  The library was only open for an hour or two each morning so that the board games and books were inaccessible most of the time.  While there was a show presented in the main lounge each evening other than the night of departure, they were not very well done.  In addition, the temperature in the lounge was set so low that even with a full house, it was uncomfortable without a sweater or wrap.

Our cabin was very comfortable with a slightly larger bathroom than I've seen on other ships.  Our room steward was excellent and kept the room clean, neat and properly stocked.  Anything we requested was there very quickly and presented with a pleasant smile.  The beds really are marvelous.  I have rarely slept so well from the first night away from home.  Be aware if anyone in your party has an allergy to feathers, the pillows and covers are all down and feathers.

Most of the dockside shopping was easily accessible but a few ports had such long piers that again, anyone with an ambulatory problem could not easily leave the dock either to shop or to access the vehicles to shore excursions.  The cruise line should look into the feasibility of providing - for a small fee - golf cart type carriers to transport passengers from the ship to the excursion/shopping locations.

We did not use the children's activities or camp but those children that were on board were not a problem, overly noisy or difficult so whatever activities there were for them must have worked well.

We did use the SPA services and they were very good.  They were quite "pricey" but during the week, the spa offered several specials that were far more reasonable than the standard massage and body treatments.

In all, this was a pleasant, relaxing cruise but not the best I've ever been on.  I doubt I will choose this cruise line again unless I am going with a large group who provide their own activities and diversions.  I would love to return to this destination again with better excursion experience. Less


Read more Carnival Victory cruise reviews >>
Read Cruise Critic's Carnival Victory Review >>

Cabin review: Carnival Victory Oceanview Main 2275

Wonderful beds, good views out the window.  Noise from the halls very noticeable.  Everything in good working order and very clean.

Port and Shore Excursions


No excursion for me at this port, but very near the ship is dockside shopping with a nice mix of the "high end" stores and native tables and kiosks. If you like to bargain, shopping here can be fun.

Read 799 Antigua Reviews

The one excursion I took was around Dominica where we visited the Yoca waterfall and the Botanic Garden. The port town is somewhat depressing as this independent island nation has a quite low income level. It is primarily an agricultural nation so those in the cities frequently are at the poverty level. Once in the countryside and up the hills, it is pretty with lovely views of the ocean and multiple waterfalls. Banana plantations and taro fields are to be seen here and there and the tour guides are quite knowledgeable and pleasant.

Read 491 Dominica Reviews

This was the last stop on our itinerary and I didn't leave the ship so have nothing to report about it.


This appears to be the lovliest and most affluent of the islands visited. I would like to come back and be able to take a sightseeing excursion. While approaching the dock, many very large, expensive homes were viewed on the hillsides.


I did not exit the ship in St. Thomas this trip as I have visited it three times in the past and have found it wonderful for jewelry and gold shopping, neither of which I was currently buying. The short hop over to St. Johns for the beach is a worthwhile trip and highly recommended.

Read 2322 St. Thomas Reviews

Thank You For Signing Up!

Please Note: To ensure delivery of your free e-letters, please add news@cruisecritic.com to your address book.
We're committed to protecting your privacy and will not rent or sell your e-mail address. By proceeding, you agree to our Privacy Policy and Terms of Use.