So many thoughts on this cruise! Let me preface by saying that I've been on 12 cruises total; most were RCCL but also NCL and Carnival. I've always preferred RCCL, going back to the Sovereign of the Seas days.
Day 1 - embarkation was smooth; we have C&A status which allowed for quick check in.
Dinner this night was basically a disaster. Service was scrambled, we got the wrong drinks multiple times, incorrect entrees, just a mess. Our neighbors complained and the server was very apologetic. Got back to the room and a laundry bag was never delivered; after over an hour of back and forth phone calls, one arrived.
Lovely cabin! We enjoyed the view right above the park cafe; noise wasn't bad at all and most days the breeze was decent. Don't make the mistake of turning off the master switch as that will also turn off your A/C (oops). Bed was comfortable; pillows were super flat but it wasn't a huge deal. The TV remote doesn't work from the bed which is probably the only annoyance I can find with the room. We would choose this room again in a heartbeat (though it's far from any elevator).