We like cruising with Celebrity and decided to try a transatlantic. It was a great experience but we like having the ports interspersed with the sea days so we probably won't do another TA.
The Reflection is a beautiful ship. The public areas are very well placed and there is always a place to sit - while there are a lot of passengers, it never feels crowded.
Cafe AlBacio is usually a favorite place for us but the coffee drinks weren't as yummy on this ship.
Great cabin - good location - bed by the bathroom - comfortable balcony
Did not stay in Rome but rather stayed in Civitavecchia where we explored the city on our own.