Chose this cruise due to close proximity of departure port and port of calls for viewing fall foliage. We were not disappointed. Ship crew is fantastic. Food was not up to usual and precious quality, but was ok. Somehow we manage to always get a rookie server in MDR. However, we were patient and still gave them extra gratuities. We all have to start somewhere! Had a wonderful dinner one night in Giovanni's. Entertainment- some good shows and some not so good. Diamond concierge and guest service reps. were super helpful, as we needed assistance to correct some discrepancies with our OBC. There was no shortage of activities, something for everyone almost evey day, evening, and night. Onboard shopping was not as good as on previous RCCL cruises. Only other con- spa/salon appointments, they always seemed to be running behind. Seemed as though they had less staff on this ship. Overall, we enjoyed the cruise, really don't like to complain, as the worst cruise is wonderful!