My wife and I are D+ members with RCCI, having cruised almost 30 times with the line. We have done everything from the 3 night Bahamas cruises to 11 nights on the Mediterranean. In fact, we did this cruise 3 times on the Enchantment in 2014. That being said, we have also been testing out Celebrity, as we are now empty nesters and enjoy a more laid back experience. I have done quite a few reviews on CC and have never done below a 3 star review.
The good - we had excellent service in the MDR and from out stateroom attendant. Both went out of their way to make sure we were enjoying our experience. As always, Mark Walker did a great job as CD, although the Love and Marriage game show ran 90 minutes including the contestant search (way too long in my opinion). The CD staff running the trivias and other activities were great.
I am glad to see that improvements are being made to Coco Cay. We had a great time snorkeling there. It's a great place to snorkel, enjoy a beach day or just relax.
The location of the cabin was good and it was much larger than the standard cabin on this ship.
We don't like Nassau so we stayed on the ship.
The new port area is nice but parking is over $20 per day. I remember paying $25 for the 3 days our first cruise.