We were on the Magic of Spain cruise and chose the itinery rather than the ship, But this was our 10th Cruise covering Island Escape,Destiny,Dream and Celebration.
The cabin I would say is the best we have had we were in a deluxe cabin directly off the atrium which was a concern but there was no noise.
I have read several reviews complaining about many things but would say that I found none of the problems that others had and had no cause to complain.