This section is for the private island, Great Stirrup Cay. Cruise critics doesn't show that in their list, so I selected Nassau again. Being a first time cruiser, I can not compare it to other cruise line private islands. I did however, enjoy it very much. It gets crowded after 10am, so go early and stake out your lounge chair and spot. They have a barbeque lunch, a band, full drink service, some line dancing, snorkeling and parasailing. No wave runners, bicycles or anything else. Snorkeling was pleasant. They list snorkeling as an excursion, but really all it is, is a full day rental on the gear, and instructions how to use it. I had all my own gear, so I didn't have to pay anything.