We chose this cruise for the itinerary and were not disappointed, Great sampler of Scotland and Ireland with some very nice bonuses - Guernsey and Honfleur (LeHavre) were unexpectedly interesting and pleasant.
Food in MDR was on the whole very good good and Servers outstanding. Some hits and misses - we learned to listen to our Server closely! Sabbatini's and Crown Grille both excellent. Buffet was standard Lido fare. Room service was marginal - cold food and failed to deliver breakfast one day.
Initial embarkation and final disembarkation went smoothly, but several ports (both tenders and docking) had some of the slowest disembarkation/re-embarkation we'd ever experienced. Queensferry (Edinburg) a particular problem.
Very nice cabin and great views. Bathroom OK with separate shower and tub but only one sink. Quiet except for expected noise from propeller/wake at aft of ship.
Holohan's at the Barge(restaurant) was incredible experience
Kelvingrove Museum was a highlight of the trip.