If I could base my rating on the Yacht Club only, it would of been a 5. One of the first days at sea, members of cruise critic met with a representative of the ship. They asked that we send Cruise Critic 3 good things we like about the ship and 1 area we thought they needed to make improvements. Frankly, it is easier the other way around. One positive factor was the Yacht Club Experience. Every day I patted myself on the back for choosing Yacht Cub versus regular passage. So for the one good thing about the ship, besides just the fact that it is a beautiful and very clean ship, is that sailing the Yacht Club is a very positive experience.
Now for the 3 areas that definitely need improvements.
1. Common area for adults only. There was over 700 children on this cruise. You could not find a lounge chair, place in a pool, quiet area or a place to sit in the buffet area, Not all people travel with children and most people want a place outdoors on a Caribbean cruise that they can enjoy the sea with a little piece and quiet.