This was my wife and my 10th cruise. 8 on RCCL and 2 on Carnival. We also had our 2 sons with us, ages 4 and 8. Overall, it was "good", but we will be reconsidering going on another Carnival cruise in the future IF we can find something that is in the same price range, here is why.
The good:
Stateroom 6J 9196. It was AMAZING. We had plenty of space for us all and we even had a twin blowup mattress on the floor and had NO space issues. PLENTY of storage also, no complaints there.
atlantis