We were loyal P&O cruisers until we decided to try the others in the market, being disappointed with the other lines we tried and their large ships with all the features, we were apprehensive to return to the line that introduced us to cruising, but completely unnecessarily so.
So we said "so-and-so does that better", another ship has a bigger lounge, but nothing that was a real annoyance like on some of the other lines we have tried. Being a small ship, there was crowds when things were on. The food and service in the restaurant was not as great and when we first sailed P&O in 2010, but still on par with other lines we have sailed.
For a 25 year old ship the cabin (6111, inside) was clean, comfortable, in good repair and roomier than others we have stayed in.
Cabin was spacious, clean and comfortable. Being below the main show lounge we did expect some noise, but the all night rehearsing of the new cast resulted in a lot of all night banging (not of the good kind), but we soon got used to it. Being forward there was some movement, but again that was expected.
Happy with the cabin