My husband and I traveled with two other couples on a southern Caribbean cruise on the Carnival Liberty. Our very first cruise was on the Carnival Mardi Gras in 1977 and we didn't cruise again until the late nineties with our three kids on the Carnival Fascination. This was followed by at least a dozen RCCL and Celebrity cruises. I'll admit we were not sure if we would like Carnival as much as its competitors. However our expectations were far exceeded.

While we still prefer the design, traffic flow and decor of RCCL and Celebrity, our cabin was wider and there was ample storage space, We also preferred the square shower to the tube. The service was extraordinary. Unobtrusive and friendly and we did not have to go to guest services at all to resolve any problems. We also felt there was less hawking to upgrade or buy things and less of a "class " system like separate dining rooms , pools etc for suite guests or high level frequent cruisers. Everything was very clean and well kept. The food overall was better than the other line and we ate in all of the venues except the steak house that required fees. The burger and buritto bars were very good and conveniently located by the pool The adult only serenity area was delightful. The entertainment was very good and we loved the comedy club.

We did only independent excursions so I cannot speak to the cruise run shore excursions. Read more