Subscribe today
Get Cruise Critic in your inbox
Your Ultimate Cruise Guide

Disney Magic Cruise Review by fortheloveofthesea: When You Wish Upon A Star


fortheloveofthesea
1 Review
Member Since 2009
90 Posts

Member Rating

Cabin Not Rated
Dining 5.5
Embarkation 5.5
Enrichment Activities 5.0
Entertainment 5.5
Family & Children 5.5
Fitness & Recreation Not Rated
Public Rooms 5.0
Rates 4.0
Service 5.5
Shore Excursions 5.0
Value for Money 5.5

Compare Prices on Disney Magic Eastern Caribbean Cruises

When You Wish Upon A Star

Sail Date: January 2009
Destination: Eastern Caribbean
Embarkation: Port Canaveral

We flew into Orlando the day before we set sail, rented a car and drove to Cape Canaveral to spend the night. We dined at a local restaurant Gregory's (excellent) and stayed at the Marriott. The next day we spent some time at Cocoa Beach and then headed over to Enterprise to return our car. Enterprise in Cape Canaveral was great because they shuttled us right to the Port and dropped us off right in front of the ship. It was also less expensive than the ground transfers that Disney offered.

Boarding the ship went very smoothly. We loved how the crew publicly welcomed our family by name as we stepped into the atrium on the ship. Our rooms (we booked two) were ready right away, so we dropped off our carry-ons and met our room steward. We then headed up to the Lido deck for lunch.

Food: We dined the majority of the time in the rotating restaurants. The quality and selection was outstanding. My youngest son loved the shrimp, so each night our Head Waiter made More sure we had some at the table. My spouse and I also dined in their adult restaurant, Palo and enjoyed the food. One tip for future Disney sailors, do book your reservation for Palo before you get on the ship. We were one of the first families onboard and they were almost completely booked up.

Children's Programs: Excellent! Our 7 year old had the best time and each day/night he did participate in his club, we'd have to drag him out. Our 9 year old had a great time as well. Our 13 year old was a little disappointed that she wasn't part of the Teen Club, "The Stack." She was instead in another club "Ocean Quest", 11-13 year olds. Prior to sailing, we had no indication that she'd be in the Ocean Quest group. Disney said that they were just making this change to their ships. They had too many complaints from parents saying that 13-17 was too broad of an age span. Of course, my spouse and I were actually relieved that she was in a more age appropriate club but she was a little disappointed with the change since there was no communication about it ahead of time.

Ports: We loved St. Maarten. The shopping, food and beaches (Dutch side, not French) were wonderful. St. Thomas was beautiful. We did excursion over the Trunk Bay on St. John for snorkeling and beach time - which was breathtaking. This we did book the excursion through Disney. Finally, we enjoyed Disney's private island, Castaway Cay. We weren't sure exactly what to expect but we had a fantastic time. The family beach was a little crowed by late afternoon but you could still find available chairs and umbrellas (which cost nothing.)

Weather: We can't complain with upper 60's to lower 80's throughout the trip. However, we did have some rain one day and some colder wind due to the cold fronts continually moving through the U.S. and then heading south through the Caribbean. I'm not sure we'd cruise again in January because of the uncertainly with the weather. It's risk on any vacation but you can't quite get away from those cold fronts during the winter months.

Overall, we had a wonderful time! Disney did a fantastic job and we were so impressed with the ship's layout, decor and cleanliness. The length of the cruise was great, as well as the port destinations. We highly recommend Disney Cruise Line to any family. You definitely get what you pay for. Less


Read more Disney Magic cruise reviews >>
Read Cruise Critic's Disney Magic Review >>

Port and Shore Excursions


We loved St. Maarten. This island is owned by both the Dutch and the French. We docked on the Dutch side of the island and for $5 per person, took a water taxi the Phillipsburg (the capital) for shopping, lunch and beach time. We first shopped the port recommended shops and walked away with some beautiful jewelry and fun souvenirs. We ate lunch on the beach (one block over from the shops) at the Barefoot Cafe -American cuisine made and served by the locals. The food was excellent and the beer was cheap. We then walked onto the beach for some fun in the sun. There were some locals trying to sell merchandise on the beach but a simple no thank you was all it took. We didn't make it over to the French side, as we tried to avoid the higher costs and nude beaches. I just couldn't imagine our younger kids reporting back to their friends and family that they saw naked people. We had a great time staying close to the ship and having it all; shopping, food and beach in the same proximity.

St. Thomas was beautiful. We did enjoy visiting a USVI and the scenary was wonderful, alhtough we didn't spend much time here. We took an excursion to St. John and visited one of the most beautiful beaches, Trunk Bay. We took a boat over the time island and then took a short taxi ride to the beach. The island definitely felt tropical with bananas, avacados and mangos hanging from the trees. The beach was truly breathtaking and we were able to enjoy some snorkeling. They have an underwater snorkel trail, which was fun and of course you could venture out on your own as well. We were sad when it came time to head back. When we got back to St. Thomas, we had a couple of hours left at port, so we headed by foot to the Fat Turtle restaurant. It was right on the water. We then checked out a few shops right by the ship before getting back on board. By the way, St. Thomas no longer requires you to go through customs as you get off the ship, so we were cleared in no time to get off the ship.
Read 2322 St. Thomas Reviews

Thank You For Signing Up!

Please Note: To ensure delivery of your free e-letters, please add news@cruisecritic.com to your address book.
We're committed to protecting your privacy and will not rent or sell your e-mail address. By proceeding, you agree to our Privacy Policy and Terms of Use.