This was our first cruise, and I think it was good. Not sure I will do it again since I am bit restless but I have never been this relaxed after a vacation.
Food: Every meal we had was warm, except the breakfast and frosted flakes in cold milk. The food was great, although going to O´Sheehans during lunch time was a bit tedious since the wait was 30-45 minutes to get food, But hey, it is busy what would you expect. Savor/Taste service was great and we got as many refills of wine we wanted. But I guess if you are obnoxuios and grumpy you get the service you deserve (as I have read many reviews stating that service is bad...)
Pool area. As everywhere else in US there needs to be music at a very loud level all the time. This is why the cruise gets a 4 instead of a 5. It would be nice to be able to have a conversation without shouting. Other than that it was great.