We had not sailed a HAL ship in a number of years. The timing was right and the deal on the cat S cabin made it a no brainer decision. I had read some negative comments on this ship but decided to see for myself. Overall our experience was a good one. I have cruised thirty something times. My expectations were not very high, considering some of the reviews. I traveled with my wife. We are mid fifties, but very active.
The boarding process was great, got there at about eleven AM and were in our cabin by 11:30. The S category cabins are exceptional. Very large 536 sq ft and have a lot of storage and closet space. Double sinks and a separate shower and tub with whirlpool jets. King size bed with very comfortable mattress and choice of pillows (down or foam) nice touch. Picture window and large veranda. Cabin 6093 is center ship and right next to elevator. I had some reservations about the elevator noise, but never heard anything. We sat at a table with another couple that also were in an S cabin, but were on the stern. They said they view was great, but could feel vibration of the engines. We felt nothing and the ride was smooth and quiet. The reports about the vibration in the main dining room, we felt were not any worse than most of the ships we have been on.
The food was about the same we have experienced on Celebrity and Princess and better than NCL and much better than Royal Caribbean. The Odyssey specialty restaurant was way above average in food quality and the steaks are at least as good as the best of the steak houses that charge an arm and leg for them. The service was OK but not on par with the food quality.