We took a Thanksgiving cruise on the Navigator of the Seas, and based on the other reviews, were a little worried. However, whatever problems RC has in the Mediterranean seem to have been resolved for the Caribbean. We had a great time.
We are experienced cruisers, having previously been on Celebrity, Princess and Holland America. Navigator completely outperformed both Princess and Holland America.
Embarkation was quick and easy we were able to get on before noon, with no lines, and with the cabins being ready by 1:00 p.m., and luggage arriving by 4:00 p.m. in plenty of time for even the early setting people to get dressed. The cabins were much larger than comparable ones on other ships, with plenty of space for clothes the built-in closets helped significantly in finding places for shorts, shirts, etc.
The cabins were great. We had an outside cabin without a balcony. Larger bed than normal. Lots of space. More than enough space for clothes built-in closet helped. Didn't hear any sounds from hallway or rooms next to us. Shower actually comfortably sized.