Just returned from a 5 night on the Liberty of the Seas and mostly I was impressed. We arrived at the port at 11:45 and we were on the ship within 30 minutes, eating lunch. The drink prices have skyrocketed, but you can bring 2 bottles of wine per stateroom on board (kids in adjoining cabin so that left plenty for us)
Unfortunately, the new menu in the dining room was pretty awful. We only ate there once and ended up at Portofino twice and chops once-- one night windjammer.... Although we had plenty of snacks and pizza to make up for it.
The ice show was spectacular as was the production "in the air", I've seen it before and forgot how good.
Loved the connecting junior suite with connecting balcony. Lots of space!!