We really loved the Star! It was our first cruise on NCL (normally we travel Carnival, but have also gone Royal and Holland America), and we really enjoyed it. I don't think I have ever seen a cruise line so focused on cleanliness, which I really appreciated. The staff truly appeared to enjoy their jobs, which I also loved. We didn't love the dining room food, but the buffet was great and changed every day. We do wish the ice cream was 24-7 (it was available from about 11 to about 7 or 8). Everything was great and we wouldn't change a thing, except maybe our cabin (11607)- it was below the main deck and so noise was an issue- the melodic trio in the atrium was SO loud and so we couldn't go to bed before 11 or 12.
Bad location, would choose another next time. Too loud