Celebrity Summit Review

Excruciatingly Bad Cruise after Great Prior Celebrity Cruises

Review for Canada & New England Cruise on Celebrity Summit
User Avatar
Quizzler
First Time Cruiser • Age 70s

Rating by category

Value for Money
Embarkation
Dining
Public Rooms
Entertainment
Service
Cabin

Additional details

Sail Date: Sep 2014
Cabin: Aqua Class

First off, my beloved spouse & I have had 3 previous GREAT cruises on Celebrity Solstice ships (in Aqua Class, because of the great food & service & ambiance, etc.)......just GREAT cruise experiences. So, before this cruise, WE LOVED CELEBRITY. After this cruise, we cancelled a Celebrity Caribbean cruise in January 2015 and may never cruise again....period. This is not intended to be unkind or rude to those who DID enjoy all or part of this cruise---we are very kind, caring, fun-loving, friendly, easy-to-get-along with, conversation-loving, fellow-traveler-loving (met some of the best people ever on this cruise and prior cruises) folks---and incredibly tolerant & patient (lots of parenting experience helped that!). But really, I have to agree with ALL of the pertinent NEGATIVE COMMENTS on previous posts (can't comment on excursions we did not take, of course, or specific personal issues fellow travelers had). This was just a beyond-all-comprehension awful Celebrity cruise experience. Secondly, I want to add to the chorus of POSITIVES ABOUT THE HARD-WORKING & CONGENIAL CREW, especially our wonderful room attendants, especially Santana, the marvelous women who work at the El Bacio specialty coffee cafe (both behind the counter and as servers), and the equally-marvelous women who served drinks at the Rendezvous----reminded us that cruising should be a fun & special experience. Thank you!

I won't reiterate all of the negative comments on the general problems with this cruise (read, for example, Nice Cruise, but Celebrity's Halo Has Slipped!, for just one excellent listing of the serious problems many of us experienced on this cruise). I have a small notebook with 12 pages listing specific complaints (most of which my spouse shared with a supervisor at Celebrity HQ when she called to cancel the January cruise---to Celebrity's credit, the supervisor prompted my spouse to talk about each and every concern with the cruise in as much detail as possible----excellent follow-up, showed genuine interest & concern---not sure if it, along with complaints by others, will have any effect on future Summit cruises, but, for Celebrity's sake, let's hope it does. If anyone wants me to list the complaints I will, but they have been adequately covered in the other posts with serious negative comments. In general, we thought the Millenium-class Summit was horribly designed (compared to the awesome later Solstice ships) and much too small & very confusing to navigate; the service, other than by the above-mentioned crew, was beyond-belief uncaring, un-pampering, un-Celebrity-like, unprofessional---some of this was because the crew was obviously overworked and understaffed as to the number of passengers on this cruise, but a lot of it just seemed to be an unbelievable "we don't really care" attitude, as if the normally attentive crew & professional staff decided that this was a good cruise for them to take a breather (and that the head folks on the ship & at Celebrity HQ had given them the go-ahead to do so)---totally bizarre for a major cruise line like Celebrity to allow this to take place, BUT IT DID TAKE PLACE! In addition, the food in the Aqua Class Blue restaurant was mediocre compared to prior Aqua cruises, especially, as one commenter mentioned, the lobster-from-hell, and the set-up & the food & the staff in the general eating area (Ocean View?) was much, much worse (the food was almost inaccessible due to the crazy-huge sneeze-glass-coverings over all of the food areas---just nuts!---normal things like milk dispensers were few and far between (one skim milk dispenser, some of the time---none a lot of the time---sheesh!), dirty plates and silverware just left on tables for the entire length of meals (at all the tables, not just the one you were eating at!), little or no table drink service, some really terrible and often cold entrees, etc., etc., etc. Oh I could go on and on and on. Just a huge, huge, huge disappointment. You get an F Celebrtiy.....thank heavens the weather was great in Acadia National Park (awesome lobster lunch as part of our paid excursion) and the wondrous Prince Edward's Island (Anne of Green Gables country and one of the most delightful & beautiful places on the planet)----those two get A's. Otherwise, Yikes!

Cabin Review

Aqua Class

To be fair, the cabins on this Solsticized-Millennium-class Summit were very good---and i think the bathroom in our room was actually better-designed than the ones on the Solstice ships we have cruised on (more room, nicer shower it seemed). And the rest of the room has lots of storage areas---nice. We did have a problem in that it took an act of God to open our terrace sliding door (even the room attendant had a hard time) and this was, of course, not fixed during the cruise. Also, the carpeting had, for some reason, several small raised bumpy areas in front of the bed (which you have to use because there is so little room between the bed & the full-wall-mirror in front of the bed (who thought THAT was a good idea??)----:bumps very difficult to notice, but easy to trip on---which is what I did one of the first nights, rather painfully twisting and hurting my back (a recurring pain in the back during the rest of the trip). But otherwise, the room was just fine and, but for the problems noted, similar to the Solstice rooms in quality.

previous reviewnext review

Find a Celebrity Summit Cruise from $222

Any Month

Get special cruise deals, expert advice, insider tips and more.By proceeding, you agree to our Privacy Policy and Terms of Use.

© 1995—2024, The Independent Traveler, Inc.