My 12-year old daughter and I just returned from a wonderful week onboard the Disney Magic. I was apprehensive; some of the reviews on this ship haven't been stellar, but we loved almost every aspect of it. Staff went out of their way to make it a great week, and I can't say enough about Guest Services. Delta Airlines lost my luggage (until the last night of the cruise); but the Guest Services staff kept calling and trying to track it down and sending us bathrobes, slippers, toiletries, and letting us do laundry for free. They really helped me keep the focus on having fun!
Food was great (dining rooms) to ok (burgers and pizza). Pools were, as others have noted, a little small. We got assigned an accessible stateroom (7636) which was downright roomy. Our stateroom host kept it tidy and clean and left my chocoholic daughter extra chocolate! We loved most of our port adventures (Jumping Back into Eternal Rome was a tad long and disorganized, though). We loved the shows and even bingo!
Great; roomy, spotlessly clean; huge verandah. Little rocky on rough sea days.