American Star Cruise Review by marthapalmer: New England Islands

American Star 2
Member Since 2014

Overall Member Rating

New England Islands

Sail Date: July 2014
Destination: USA
Embarkation: Other

This cruise was extremely inconsistent in service, dining, entertainment and excursions For the amount of money we spent (over $8000) we expected to have outstanding service and dining. Real lobster crackers are a must for whole lobsters - not nut crackers. I could only get to 1/2 of the meat. Poached eggs had to be sent back 3 times because the yolks were overcooked and hard. I had a meal of chicken parmesan which was inedible. The sauce and cheese I was able to pick up in one big hunk. The chicken itself was hard and dry and the risotto was hard and glue-like. Our server was in tears due to the chef attacking her in the kitchen. On several days we were in the cabin in the morning with the Do Not Disturb sign on the door. When we left on an excursion we took the sign off and expected the room to be cleaned- it was not. The ship is only 7 years old and is looking shabby. Now, that all being said, we spoke to the Hotel Manager, who was appreciative of our constructive criticism and had More a discussion with the staff and the chef. Hopefully things will be corrected, but I do not think I could recommend American Cruise Lines to a friend. It is too bad because the itineraries are very interesting. Way too much money for the product delivered. Less

Published 07/27/14

2 Helpful Votes

Read more American Star cruise reviews >>
Read Cruise Critic's American Star Review >>

Compare Prices on American Star USA Cruises

Cabin review: 215

The cabins need to be updated They are looking shabby and old. Space was good.

Member Since 2014
Enrichment Activities
Family & Children
Fitness & Recreation
Onboard Experience
Public Rooms
Shore Excursions
Value for Money
Share feedback
Thank you!  Cruise Critic values your feedback.
How can we improve this page?
Skip X

See American Star deals up to 82% off:

October Deals
American Star 73% Loved It

7 Night Chesapeake Bay Cruise
See all American Star Deals >>