This was my second TA on the Disney Magic. First time in 2011.
The ship refurbishment was a big improvement.
Pluses: Embarkation smooth, The new buffet at the back. The food at lunch: great shrimp , roasts, salads etc.
The service. The maitre d in the dining room. Movies all day. the promenade deck. The entertainment. the adult pool.Castaway cay. Alcohol policy. Free sodas. Fabulous weather and seas. great cooking demonstrations.
The negatives: The desserts at diner. the screaming kids (sometimes at diner) the adult entertainment after 10. Poor visibility of the star shower. Breakfast, no good brown bread or brown muffins. Spa poor.
Compared to 2011. I liked the entertainers better in 2011. Less kids in 2011. Better ship in 2014.