We had a fabulous time on this ship and itinerary. The ship was great. The main dining room, theater, lounges were all very clean and welcoming. We had a lower inside room and were surprised at how well we liked it. It was plenty roomy for a 7 night cruise with lots of drawer space. The bathroom was even a little (a little) bigger than expected. The cruise staff were all very polite and helpful. If anything, the ship is not laid out as intuitively as other ships. I saw several people many days into the cruise still trying to figure their way around. Also there is no promenade or expansively open area on the ship. This made my wife feel like the ship was not as large as it actually was. (Both positively and negatively)
The itinerary, Southern Caribbean, was excellent. I would happily go again as there were places we didn't get to see that we wanted and places we would love to visit again. I highly recommend Crane Beach in Barbados and the Eco Kayak tour in Antigua.
The absolute best thing about this trip was the food. We didn't go to any of the specialty restaurants as we felt the food in the main dining area was already exceptional (and already paid for).