The Carnival Liberty was very clean and our room was great as always, and we did have fun visiting Half Moon Cay, San Juan, St. Thomas, and Grand Turk. This cruise we went out on our own and had a lot of fun, as for Grand Turk if you are going Scuba or snorkeling just enjoy the day at Margaretville, DO NOT bother going on an Island tour (the hop on hop off bus is hop off but rarely hop back on).
American Menu: We were very disappointed with the "NEW" American Menu, Carnival eliminated several very popular deserts and main courses that we use to really enjoy, the wait staff seemed somewhat flustered by the new menu, and our wait staff didn't seem to have the time to get to know us like they had on all of our previous cruises.
Guy Burgers, and the Blue and Red Iguana Bars are a nice additions (had these on the Breeze). The Bar staff in the Serenity area were extremely friendly and made a point of knowing us and what we liked to drink.