The ship itself was beautiful. The itinerary was perfect, all beautiful islands with much to offer, Nassau, Tortola, St. Thomas and Antigua. Would highly recommend these places.
The food on the lido deck was typical cruise fare in the buffet, plenty too offer and relatively short lines. The Guy's burgers were fabulous. Did not care for the burrito bar. The Italian fee restaurant was awesome. Highly recommend that, and you can eat in there for lunch without a fee with limited pasta selections. We did the for fee steak restaurant one night and were very sorry we did. The atmosphere was too casual, despite a dress code, there were people dressed in shorts and tshirts. We ordered our steak medium well and it came out burnt and well done. Not even edible. We had lobster as well and it was the same as in main dining room. Appetizer selections were no different than what you can get in main dining room too. It is located on the Promenade Deck 5, so your view are people walking and talking on the lanai. Just had no "added" luxury feel at all. The floor was slippery and many people slipped and fell. I would highly NOT recommend wasting your money. I would have to give kudos to the servers, however.
As far as entertainment, the Cruise director certainly had high energy and did a great job. We enjoyed Ben in the Piano Bar, the adult comedy shows and the guitar singers. Angie, who played guitar and sang on the Lido deck was simply amazing. It was a joy to listen to her and we followed her wherever she played. Each night, the Red Frog Pub had live entertainment (which Angie was there 3 of our 8 nights) and the best atmosphere. The shows were absolutely horrendous. Poor singing, relying on cartoon characters and just not put together well at all.
There was a strong sewage smell AFT on all decks. We had an aft balcony and while you could not smell it inside the cabin, in the corridors and on other decks above, it was horrible. However, overall the ship is a great ship, very friendly staff all around and great itinerary.