I've read numerous reviews regarding the Island Princess, its appearance, its staff, the quality and variety of food available; both in the dining rooms and at the Horizon Court Buffet.
I wonder if the less than positive comments have come from people who have sailed on a different ship than I did.
For 14 days from Labor Day through September 16, 2013 our family was pampered and spoiled by the most incredible staff of professionals anyone could hope to come across. We did not find the "rust" or dated appearances that others seem to notice. We were on a ship that while not brand new was certainly not old by any sense of the word. Nor was it nothing but a huge floating resort with 20 swimming pools and too many specialty restaurants to describe that moved from port to port during the night. It was as accurately described a beautiful cruise ship.
Perfect location, great mini-suite with more than enough room for 2 people. Tub shower was perfect for someone who has a little difficulty moving around in just a shower stall. Very quiet part of the ship. Even though we did not have a balcony we were right outside the entire bow balcony on Deck 10. Only a very few people discovered this very special space and many times we had it to ourselves.