We went on the Mariner in 2001 during its Inaugural season. We also did Alaska but from Vancouver to Anchorage. We were extremely impressed with the ship in 2001. My in-laws wanted to go again in 2006 and I was reluctant to take the same ship with pretty much the same itinerary (only reversed). I'm so glad we did! The Mariner was even better than 5 years ago! Everything about the ship, crew, service, quality of food, entertainment, kid's program, etc. was excellent! My only complaint is that we had to leave the ship after 7 days!
The food at ALL of the venues was excellent. We tried every restaurant at least once and we enjoyed every meal.
We used Club Mariner for my 5 and 7 year olds. They had a wonderful time while we were able to enjoy quiet meals, especially in the evenings.