Here are our experiences on the Liberty, keep in mind that was our first cruise and we had nothing to compare it to. Steve (my better half), and our adult kids, college age, had the time of our lives.
The ship: be ready to be amazed. The ship is beautiful with ELEGANT dEcor and amazing and bold art. We are kind of modern with our tastes and I hate gaudy hotels, and this was pleasing and surprising in all areas. The dining room is more classical but charming in its frilly style.
The rooms are ROOMY and nice looking, everything is so new. We had a balcony room which is awesome to have the space, hang out late afternoon with a drink, during the day with a book, and at night with a peek at moon/ waves etc.