We booked this cruise despite all the negative reviews we had read as we didn't want to waste 4 of our precious vacation days at sea while in Hawaii. We also didn't want to sail on the Wind as we had heard several reviews about her showing her age, etc and decided that a new ship would suit us better.
We had a fabulous time and I am still wondering about all the negative reviews we read. I can only assume that your personal expectations and attitude will have a large impact on your vacation.
The ship itself was stunning, very well laid out and very clean in all the common areas. We were very impressed with the planning and decor that went into it.