Subscribe today
Get Cruise Critic in your inbox
Your Ultimate Cruise Guide

MSC Poesia Cruise Review by travellovers2: MSC - never again


travellovers2
7 Reviews
Member Since 2007
767 Posts

Member Rating

Cabin 4.0
Dining 1.0
Embarkation 3.0
Enrichment Activities 1.0
Entertainment 1.0
Family & Children Not Rated
Fitness & Recreation Not Rated
Public Rooms 4.0
Rates 3.0
Service 1.0
Shore Excursions 3.0
Value for Money 3.0

Compare Prices on MSC Poesia Western Caribbean Cruises

MSC - never again

Sail Date: February 2013
Destination: Western Caribbean
Embarkation: Fort Lauderdale (Port Everglades)

We sailed on the MSC Poesia on Feb 2nd to the Western Caribbean. We have been to these ports before, except for Falmouth, so we mainly took this cruise to experience MSC. We heard their ship was beautiful, and that is exactly all we got, a beautiful ship.

Embarkation: we are glad this time we chose to have a relative drop us off. The terminal they use is complicated. You have to walk around to get in the terminal through a side entrance. Although we do not have a walking problem, we kept thinking of the older passengers that had to do all that walking just to get in the terminal. Second time we had to sit around and wait for a number to be called so we can board the ship. The first time we did this in Disney CL and now in MSC. The wait was not long, maybe about 20 mins, but it doesnt make any sense.

So finally we board the ship. The ship is not that big, but it is beautifully decorated. We were able to go straight to our cabin and drop off our carry on and head to the More lunch buffet. The first lunch was not that good and we were hoping it was not a sign of things to come, unfortunately it was. In the lunch buffet they had a cake with a sign that said "Display only, do not eat" yet it had 1/4 of it missing. Ha! That's what happens on a ship where more than half the guests do not speak english!! It was funny.

When we reserved we asked for a late seating, which we got, but we were told that we could not ask for the table size until we were on board. So we waited to get on board and were told they did not have a table for two. We saw a lot of empty tables for two throughout the cruise. So we got a table for 8, but only got to meet three other guests that showed up.

The food in the MDR was not that good. My husband left his plate half full more often than not. Since I have allergies to some herbs and spices, in all the other 15 cruises we have taken, the Maitre'd takes my order the night before and they prepare my food without the herbs and spices I am allergic to, not here. I was told that I had to order the same night and nothing was good for me to eat. So, I ended up eating salmon and mashed potatoes every single night, except for one night that we went to the Japanese specialty restaurant where we had a great meal. The desserts were terrible, except for the tiramisu they had ONE night and was never on the menu, it was one of those nights that they walked around to music carrying a tiramisu. The ice cream was horrible, which was shocking because we had great gelato in Italy.

The feeling we got from the MDR staff is that they were rushing us. My husband made a comment to the waiter that usually they take the dinner order first then they bring a dessert menu, not here. You have to order your dessert and coffee at the same time you order your food. Most of the nights we had to tell them that we wanted to order drinks, then it was a sit and wait deal for someone to come take our order. My food order was taken after everyone else at the table because I had to wait for the other guy just to tell him I wanted salmon and mashed potatoes since he told me that everything else on the menu had spices and herbs. Then my food would arrive about 8 minutes after everyone else at the table. It was embarrassing because they insisted on waiting for me to also eat.

This was the first cruise that we sat in a lounge and had to get up to order drinks at the bar. Also, if there was any staff walking around, we had to wave at them to come take our order. One night we sat in a lounge and watched the guy walk around adjusting his clothes without approaching anyone until they waved at him. So I am not sure if this is their policy or their lack of interest.

We went to the buffet every morning for breakfast which was ok, how can you mess up breakfast? Ha! But, lunch was another story. My husband ended up eating pizza every day because the rest of the food was terrible, me? I asked the head guy that was walking around the buffet area if i could get a plate with mashed potates without parsley on it and he started talking in a very LOUD voice telling me in his broken english "Allergies here NO, you have to go downstairs" I can assure you that if you were there you heard him as well. So I went to the MDR for lunch and they were clueless as to what their food had in it. One time my husband had to explain to the Maitre'D how to make me a cream sauce and just put it on top of some pasta. It's an italian cruise line, you think they would know how to make a sauce with heavy cream and parmessan cheese.

Besides the terrible food, we found the ship to be beautiful. The theater was one of the most beautifully decorated theaters we have seen on a ship. Too bad we can't say the shows were good. They had the same group of people singing and dancing every night. They just changed clothes and music. The first night we were ready to see our first show and then we find out they were having muster drills for the passengers that got on later than 4:30, because the ship leaves port at 7pm. So no show the first night.

The cruise director was one lady and a guy, I think. They both stood in front of the theater every night and she said the same thing in 4 different languages. So you sit through this every night. Maybe they should ask if people that speak that language are there and that way the announcement would not be so long. She spoke very very fast so you would hear people laughing at her all the time. It was uncomfotable to sit through this every night.

It's a shame that they have such poor service, but it's their loss. We have taken 16 cruises in 8 yrs and we have one 7nt and a 14nt coming up for the rest of this year, so it's their loss. I would not choose MSC again. You need to have more than a beautiful ship to offer your guests. If you value customer service, this is not the ship to take. Less


Read more MSC Poesia cruise reviews >>
Read Cruise Critic's MSC Poesia Review >>

Cabin review: MSC Poesia Superior Balcony Ungaretti Deck

Port and Shore Excursions


We have been to Cozumel many timnes so we mostly walk around the downtown area now and eat or shop. There is not much to do there. On another cruise we took the tour to Tulum ruins and loved it. Cozumel has three different piers but if your ship docks in Punta Langosta then you are right in front of the downtown area. There is a water taxi that takes you across to Playa del Carmen, but we did that before and found the same thing, shops and restaurants, so we prefer to just make it a day in downtown Cozumel.
Read 3137 Cozumel Reviews

We were apprehensive about getting off in any port in Jamaica again. We have been to Montego Bay and Ocho Rios before, but were were surprised by Falmouth. The port area was very nice. You have shops and they are building in Margarita Ville. Once you get to the end of the port area, that is another story. So we chose to stay in the port area and enjoy it. We even did some jewelry shopping which we got a great bargain. If you want to take a trolley to go around Falmouth, it cost $20 per person. We chose to use our cash to buy rum and stay with a good image of Falmouth by staying inside the port area. I highly recommend that you get off here and enjoy this area. They have dancers entertaining you and we saw some guys on stilts wanting to take a picture with peple but then they all got over the people asking for money, so we took their picture from far away.
Read 491 Falmouth Reviews

We have been to Grand Cayman many times and enjoy walking around shopping. We buy perfumes here every time we go. We enjoy sitting in an outside cafe and having drinks. Once we took the tour to see the stingrays and hell, but now we just like to shop and relax.

We went to Roatan 8 yrs ago and we heard that it had been updated so we were looking forward to this stop. We took a tour to the west end of the island looking forward to the shopping district they supposedly have in front of a beach area. What a lie!!! When you arrive there after a 30 mins ride, the beach area is a few feet of sand, where the sand ends is where the narrow two lane road starts and on the other side are shacks called stores. They are very small souvenir stores or bars. You can hardly walk down the road because there are no sidewalks. So you have to walk on dirt and watch out for the cars/trucks/buses coming back and forth. The area is not even a mile long. If you want to sit, you have to go inside a bar and order something. There is nowhere to sit. If you want to sit on the lounge chairs on the sand, you have to pay $5 per chair. Forget about taking a nap, you have kids and women CONSTANTLY coming around shoving bracelets and stuff in your face for you to buy, even if you act like you're asleep, they ask you if you want to buy something. These were very long hours to wait under very intense heat and no shade except for the time we went inside the bar and paid $5 for one beer and a coke.
Read 1660 Roatan Reviews

Thank You For Signing Up!

Please Note: To ensure delivery of your free e-letters, please add news@cruisecritic.com to your address book.
We're committed to protecting your privacy and will not rent or sell your e-mail address. By proceeding, you agree to our Privacy Policy and Terms of Use.