This was our sixth cruise, the others being on Holland America (1), NCL (1), and Costa (3). Executive Summary: We had a great experience with Celebrity and will be back with them!
Cabin: We were in Concierge Class. Cabin size seemed a bit cramped compared to our experience in other ships, but not terribly smaller. Could have used curtain between bed area and lounge area, like we have had on NCL and Holland America. The cabin attendants were pretty good, and it was nice to have daily hor d'oeuvres appear in the room automatically.
Food: Here is where this cruise excelled! Whether from the main dining room, the Oceanview Cafe, or room service, the food was pretty good. Not too salty, as we have experienced on other cruise lines. Some of the food quality surpassed that of our local restaurants, which is remarkable given the institutional nature of the food preparation. We typically have low expectations of cruise food, and it is typically met. Not this time: Celebrity exceeded our expectations!