Subscribe today
Get Cruise Critic in your inbox
Your Ultimate Cruise Guide

Norwegian Star Cruise Review by Northbay: NCL STAR REPO - THE BIG APPLE TO BIG EASY - OCTOBER 21-NOV 4


Northbay
1 Review
Member Since 2007
680 Posts

Member Rating

Cabin 5.5
Dining 5.0
Embarkation 5.0
Enrichment Activities 3.0
Entertainment 5.0
Family & Children Not Rated
Fitness & Recreation 5.0
Public Rooms 5.0
Rates 5.5
Service 5.0
Shore Excursions Not Rated
Value for Money 5.0

Compare Prices on Norwegian Star USA Cruises

NCL STAR REPO - THE BIG APPLE TO BIG EASY - OCTOBER 21-NOV 4

Sail Date: October 2012
Destination: USA
Embarkation: New York (Manhattan)

We are a retired couple from Canada, and this is our 25th cruise, having cruised with NCL about 12 times. This was an absolutely amazing fall vacation. We were initially a bit concerned about travelling in October in the Caribbean, and were very fortunate not to have encountered Hurricane Sandy as we were ahead of her when she hit New York. Great warm weather on this cruise, with only rain on one day, and a couple of windy days.

We travelled from Toronto to New York by Greyhound Bus during the night, an 11 hour trip, arriving in New York early in the morning. We stayed at the Westin New York Grand Central, formerly the New York Helmsley, at an extremely reasonable price through Hotwire. A large cc group had booked rooms a year in advance. Extremely large room with a view of Empire State Building. Three days spent in New York City was definitely not enough, but we were able to scratch the surface and plan to go back again to enjoy some of the museums and a play. The More HOHO bus 2 day pass worked extremely well for us. The highlight was Times Square, followed by Grand Central Station, trip up to the top of the Rock and an evening ride to Brooklin to enjoy the scenery at nighttime of Manhattan.

One of our cruise critic buddies had reserved a couple of vans to take us to the port on embarkation day, which worked extremely well, especially since there was a bike race going on that day. Our van driver was extremely pleasant and seemed to get us there in no time at all. Our group was well organized by our great leader, Catherine. Everything went smoothly, porters took our luggage, advance tips that were collected were given to him, and luggage miraculously disappeared. Check in was extremely fast, a very short line, and we gathered in a lounge to wait to board our ship, which we did in less than an hour, having been met by the concierge and a few other familiar faces.
As a group we were escorted to Cagney's for lunch. Since our cabins were ready we eagerly went to see our home for 14 days. What a surprise! We were upgraded from a minisuite to an enormous family suite with four large sets of floor to ceiling windows, large bathroom with double sinks and bathtub, dining table with 4 chairs, large sofa and two extra comfy chairs. A very nice surprise. This was our first time in a suite and we totally enjoyed being pampered and spoiled by our room steward, Benjamin, who kept our room immaculate & spotless, and had a talent for making a different towel animal every night, and our butler, Made, who set the dining table with such flair when we ordered room service. We felt we were eating in a fine restaurant. Made was always dapperly dressed, very respectful, and gentlemanly, showed us how to use the Lavazzo coffee machine, bringing in a fresh basket of fruit, which he refilled during the week, delivered hors deuves and cookies every afternoon, dvd's, chilled wine & water, etc.etc. The ice bucket was always full. Excellent service by these gentlemen. A+

NCL STAR, appropriately named The Happy Ship, is a great ship with a fantastic crew, who work extremely well together in an attempt to ensure that everyone feels special and has a great vacation. Nothing is too much for them. The officers are visible throughout the ship, and seem to find time in their busy, hectic schedules to exchange pleasantries with some of the passengers. I haven't noticed this on any other cruise line that we've been on. They are so upbeat, and are always smiling as if they do enjoy their jobs. This comes down from the very top and filters all the way down. They selflessly cater to our every needs, and we are so grateful to be lucky enough to be able to cruise on NCL ships. Super service, far superior to any other cruiseline. Granted there are times when the odd meal is not the best, but the majority of the time it's extremely good and great value for our money.

Our cruise critic group was fortunate enough to be invited to 2 sailaway parties in the garden villas. What a spectacular way to leave New York City, passing by some famous landmarks, the Statue of Liberty, Ground Zero, Staten Island, with an air and sea escort, and barely making it under the Verrazano bridge (or so it seemed). An awesome start to a great vacation.

On our first night we requested the concierge, Monica, who, by the way is one of the best, to make reservations for a group of 16 in the MDR Versailles at 6:30. She achieved this without a hitch, and some of us enjoyed the lobster dinner with the accompanying beverage. Ordering 2 was not a problem. There was an extensive menu to choose from. A great start to an amazing cruise getting to know our fellow cruise mates in such a beautiful room with glitzy chandeleirs, ambient lighting, and superb service.

We enjoyed the majority of our dinners in the MDR, or Aqua, which is usually less crowded, and also tried 4 of the specialty restaurants. The meals in LeBistro, Cagneys, Moderno and LaCuchina were most enjoyable and certainly worth the upcharge IMHO. The salad bar at Moderno is one of the best; the only complaint I have is the music from the atrium, which sometimes makes it difficult to hear one another. A secluded quieter area would have been better IMHO.

The entertainment on the Star was great. We enjoyed Elements the best, followed by Band on the Run and the Crew Show (Nih Liu and Flarita, you are so talented). There was also the usual juggler, comedian, trapeze acts, and hypnotist. The cruise director, Kyle, was extremely good, having been in the business for 22+ years, and his talent showed through.

THE MARKET CAFE: Although it tends to get extremely crowded in the mornings, it's a great place at night when the singing chef is entertaining. The dance floor gets quite crowded as people congregate in this venue to enjoy his singing and antics, and dance the night away. Honourable mention should be made of the Washy Washy guys who greet you profusely before entering the room. They are so upbeat. Clean hands sure help to stop the spread of germs.
I understand on a surprise inspection at one of the ports NCL got a 99 percent rating.

The cruise critic group spent countless hours organizing a myriad of events, the top one IMHO being a horse race, which was the most exciting and enthusiastic group activity we had ever done on a ship. There were 5 horses and each represented an island; our Canadian Horse, Aruba, who started out very slowly, eagerly galloped to win the second race.
The CC group also organized a Mardi Gras Parade, Halloween Party in the Gardenvilla, complements of Denise & others, Octoberfest luncheon, complements of John & others, Bridge Tour, LRC games, mahjong, Slot Pull, Cabin Crawl, and Indian meal. There was so much going on, no time to get bored, and all cc members were welcome to join in. These events were very well attended and a good time was had by a majority of people.
A great big THANK YOU to all the organizers.

PORTS: Since we had been to all the ports before, we did not book many organized excursions but did our own thing. In the past I've found that it's also easy getting off the ship in most Caribbean ports and doing an island tour with either a group or by private taxi, after negotiating an itinerary, length of tour, and price. Know what you're getting and paying for.

A review of each port is done separately and follows this review.

NEW ORLEANS: What a delightful enjoyable place. Since we were in transit, after a relaxing breakfast, we got off the ship around 9:15, went through customs very easily (however other people with luggage had an extremely difficult time due to a few problems with the first cruiseship entering the port for the year).

We went to Harrah's to meet some friends who were joining us on the following cruise, and then took the trolley to Cafe Du Monde. Since there was an extremely heavy downpour, this curtailed our visit this time. We returned to Riverwalk where we spent a couple of hours browsing around the stores, had lunch, and then returned to board the ship. We were fortunate to get on the ship within half hour as we were in transit, but there were numerous angry people waiting in line to board as there was a delay.

We loved this cruise, and give exceptionally high marks to the crew and especially to Yannis, the food and beverage director, who we felt did an amazing job despite all the problems he encountered. He kept his cool, and bottom line, did a great job working under pressure, standing out in the heavy rain, without a complaint; just doing his job despite the bad weather.

Our hats also go off to all the crew members who had to pitch in and do so many extra hours to unload the ship in a timely manner.

Thank you NCL. We will definitley be cruising with you in the future and can't wait until we board again. You treat us royally. THANK YOU.

I have not attached photos as other cc members have done a great job with their videos. Less


Read more Norwegian Star cruise reviews >>
Read Cruise Critic's Norwegian Star Review >>

Cabin review: Norwegian Star 12016

We were upgraded to a family suite, SJ category, suite #12016, on Deck 12. A very quiet location, close to the library. We absolutely loved this cabin. The space was over 400 sqft with huge bathroom, double sinks, bathtub, shower, tiled floor, and 4 sets of separate closet space. The living room and bedroom were extremely huge and could be divided by a wooden partition from the sitting area and dining area. There were also 2 sets of night tables, one at the foot of the bed that I used to store papers and shoes. There was also a huge oblong wooden table in between the sofa and 2 plush sitting room chairs. A most comfortable room with 4 huge panes of glass to enjoy the beautiful sea down below. The best view we've ever had. We spent many hours relaxing in our most comfortable room, not bumping into one another any where. Would love to get the same cabin again.

Port and Shore Excursions


ANTIGUA: We did a 4 hr. private island tour with another couple through Lawrence of Antigua. Excellent driver and guide. Antigua has so many beautiful sandy beaches, 365 in total, it's hard to pick a favorite. I had explored some of them in the past on a week long vacation there, so this time an excursion around the island was warranted; visited Shirley's Heights, for beautiful photo shots down to the lovely blue water, Betty's Hope, Devil's Bridge with blow hole (where our driver drove on the coral path so a disabled passenger wouldn't miss this magnificent view, Nelson's Dockyard, and English Harbour, We highly recommend this company. Our driver, Christopher, was very informative, spoke excellent English, and even stopped to get us some cut up fresh fruit from a street vendor. A+ service.
Read 802 Antigua Reviews

ARUBA: Taxi ride with another very delightful couple to Palm Beach dropping off at the Riu Beach Hotel; cost $14 USD for 4 people, and $35 for cabana rental and chairs for all. There were various prices down the beach. Great beach for swimming, relaxing & walking; the ocean was slightly dirty because there was a bad storm and rain the previous night. Lots of motorized water toys for rent e.g. seadoos, banana boats, wind surfing, plus kayaks.
Read 682 Aruba Reviews

Bar Hop

(5)
COZUMEL: We were celebrating our leader and her husband's wedding anniversary, and the group had pre-arranged a BarHop Tour to the east side of the Island in a 45 seater modern air conditioned bus. We were met at Starbucks by our extremely knowledgeable guide who escorted us to the bus; we visited 4 great small bars, stopping for about 45 minutes at each location; unspoiled and private, and not developed as yet, however extremely scenic, and off the beaten path. Since we're always looking for a new experience in these ports, this was an extremely enjoyable group excursion. The first drink was free and others available for purchase. Great to relax in the many hammocks around the beach and listen to the surf. So very relaxing I almost fell asleep. However, because of the large coral boulders and waves, swimming was a little difficult at a couple of the beaches. But the scenery sure made up for that. It was idyllic. Cost $40 pp. We left pier at 9:30 and returned at 2:15, and had some time to enjoy some shopping at the pier also. It's a 10 minute walk from the pier to go to a megashop for water, etc, plus an outdoor market, however there are multiple booths closer to pier for shopping for the usual touristy things. I always purchase vanilla here. My favorite shop at the pier is Los Cincos Soles.
Read 21 Bar Hop Reviews

CURACAO: Very pedestrian friendly. We walked 10 minutes from the pier, crossed the bridge and the waterfront market, enjoying the beautifully coloured picturesque buildings, sights & smells, and took a local bus for $1 pp to Jan Thiel Beach, which is about a 35 minute bus ride. Small entrance fee plus a minimal cost for cabana rental or palapas with loungers. Great small sandy beach ideal for swimming, snorkelling and relaxing. We met a couple from the cruise ship and spent a very enjoyable day on the beach with them.
Read 502 Curacao Reviews

ST. THOMAS: Toured around the island in an OPEN AIR sightseeing bus with a group of approx 25, where we were also able to spend time shopping and swimming, with flexibility of being able to return to the ship early, if desired. Our Queen, Bonnie, singlehandedly arranged this in advance and I felt it was excellent value: $25 pp. 9:30-3:00 approx. The water is so blue here and great for swimming and snorkeling . Shopping was great for jewelry and liquor. Free Internet was available in a jewelry store close to the market. Public washrooms also available across from the park.
Read 2323 St. Thomas Reviews

Thank You For Signing Up!

Please Note: To ensure delivery of your free e-letters, please add news@cruisecritic.com to your address book.
We're committed to protecting your privacy and will not rent or sell your e-mail address. By proceeding, you agree to our Privacy Policy and Terms of Use.