Subscribe today
Get Cruise Critic in your inbox
Your Ultimate Cruise Guide

Carnival Freedom Cruise Review by shipboard mom: 63rd Cruise and the most disappointing and disgusting of all


shipboard mom
1 Review
Member Since 2010
0 Posts

Member Rating

Cabin 5.0
Dining 2.0
Embarkation 4.0
Enrichment Activities 3.0
Entertainment 4.0
Family & Children Not Rated
Fitness & Recreation 5.0
Public Rooms 3.0
Rates 2.0
Service 3.0
Shore Excursions 2.0
Value for Money 2.0

Compare Prices on Carnival Freedom Southern Caribbean Cruises

63rd Cruise and the most disappointing and disgusting of all

Sail Date: August 2012
Destination: Southern Caribbean
Embarkation: Fort Lauderdale (Port Everglades)

This cruise was my annual mother/daughter cruise with my 25 year old daughter. We choose the Freedom because of the itinerary. We live in Central Florida and went down to Ft. Lauderdale the day prior to the cruise. We stayed at the Hilton Garden Inn and with the room, we were able to leave our car at the hotel and received free transportation to and from the port. I was very glad they offered this because as usual the parking at this port was a nightmare.

We did check in rather fast as we are VIP members. Our room was a suite on the seventh floor and quite comfortable and our room steward was great. Being I am Diamond, the housekeeping staff went above and beyond and the supervisors stopped by several times to make sure our room was in good order. Being Diamond, the hotel staff, bartenders, casino, wait staff treated me excellent. However, the purser's desk was another story. They were among the rudest bunch of people I have ever encountered on the high seas. However, I did More notice that they bent over backwards to accommodate first and second time cruisers. Odd as they did not extend the same courtesy to myself as a Diamond member or Platinum members.

The fellow passengers were the rudest and lowest of the low I have ever cruised with. Manners did no exist in the least. Buffet line was a nightmare and included people putting their hands in food and touching. Dress code was whatever you wanted in the Lido Buffet including bathing suits, bare feet and men with no tops on.I was appalled at the outfits in the dining room. Worst yet, was going to the steakhouse and being subjected to people dressed in jeans, flip flops, visors. This is supposed to be a five star experience. NOT. Add to it, the people who had a screaming infant and another couple with an out of control toddler who actually sat on the bar. Sadly, the staff was catering to this crowd. Other passengers left and complained to the purser. One couple who was only gold did get a meeting with the Hotel Director and reimbursed. I, however, was not given the courtesy of either a meeting with the head of Guest Relations or the Purser. Evidently they were in an emergency meeting for 72 hours but oddly, the Director had time to meet with a Gold couple. Interesting?I was told by one purser too bad, it was for free. This was my ONLY comp as a Diamond member, a one time free dinner at the steakhouse. I told the rude woman NO, it was not free. I cruised 33 times with Carnival so I earned one lousy dinner and it should have been nice. Only due to the persistence of a wonderful maitre'd, Chubby, did I get another steak dinner. This man was an original Carnival man from years gone by where service was great. He could not believe that no one cared in Guest Relations.

I might add the back pool which was adult only , the cover to the pool was constantly closed and therefore, it was extremely hot back there. As a cancer survivor, I cannot tolerate heat and went downstairs to Guest Relations. Once again, I encountered a RUDE purser who told me well go to the main pool. I explained to her that was not satisfactory as I did not feel like being exposed to screaming out of control children in diapers. There was no supervision. We found out that the men in charge of opening the lid were off the boat.

I think security was afraid of the guests as they seemed to have no control. To mention a few of the episodes that we encountered were guests actually urinating on the doors of cabins, woman being groped in the casino, you could not walk down the strip outside of the casino unless you wanted to be greeted by vulgar comments and there was a man in the main pool doing something extremely sexual and disturbing. When a woman screamed the staff laughed and it took security over a half hour to respond. At this point, this disgusting man was gone. Security never even reported this to the Hotel Director. On the last sea day, those of us that were confined to the back pool and repeat cruisers had a meeting with the Hotel Director to explain our disappointment and disgust as to this cruise. He seemed surprised. His response was there were a large number of cruisers as this was the last week before school started. That is nonsense as I have cruised this week before and never ever have I encountered such rude and disgusting people in my life or guest services who did not want to handle anything to make any one happier.

As far as being Diamond, there are NO perks to stay loyal to Carnival. Big deal,you get on the ship first and as far as disembarkation, you are NOT the first ones off unless you lug your own luggage off the ship. If you do not carry your own luggage, you have to stand in the lobby. Unlike other lines, they do not even have a special room to wait in and offer you danish and coffee. Big deal you can have your laundry washed every day as opposed to Platinum which is twice a week. You get a once in a lifetime free steak dinner. You also get ONE cocktail for the whole cruise but you can only that that one drink at either breakfast or lunch. Really??? After this experience, I will be going back to Royal Caribbean where this unruly behavior is not tolerated and you truly are treated like Diamond as they have some very nice perks including a Concierge Club.

I am sad that Carnival is cutting so many costs as it was obvious the food has taken a downward turn and concentrating on catering to people who probably will never cruise again unless there is a great deal. You would think they would want to take care of the guests who have been loyal to them. As I stated earlier, this was my 63rd cruise and by far the worst cruise I have ever been on. The first time I was actually happy to get off a ship and come home. Less


Read more Carnival Freedom cruise reviews >>
Read Cruise Critic's Carnival Freedom Review >>

Cabin review: Carnival Freedom Suite Empress

Suite had large closet space, nice balcony, large bathroom but very tiny whirlpool tub, location was very noisy as too close to elevators.

Port and Shore Excursions


I absolutely love Aruba and have been there many times by ship and plane. Being I have been to the island, I did not feel it necessary to book an excursion. We got off the ship and grabbed a taxi and headed to Palm Beach which is in the heart of the big resorts. At the beach, you were able to rent umbrellas and chairs and if water sports were your desire, plenty of things to do. What is nice about this location is that when you have enough beach, you can walk to the resorts and grab something to eat, gamble or shop. The shops around the dock are also numerous. My only disappointment was that the ship did not stay all day and our time in one of the nicest ports of all was so short.
Read 681 Aruba Reviews

Boat Tour

(4)
We took a small boat from the dock to the beach. We were stuck on the top of the boat and the seas were extremely rough. The scenery was nice on the way to the beach. When we got there, it turned out to be a very crowded public beach. The water was nice as it was surrounded by a wall to break the waves. However, this excursion would have cost half the price to take a taxi and go on your own. We did choose to take a taxi back to the port as we did not enjoy the rough seas on the small boat to the beach. The taxi ride gave us an opportunity to see a bit of the island. This was a beautiful island with nice ships and restaurants within walking distance of the dock.

Previously enjoyed this stop. However, this time it was not as enjoyable as the beach has really had a lot of erosion and there were numerous huge rocks in the water. This was dangerous if you have trouble standing and you should be very careful. There is Margaritaville with a huge pool and bar but unless you are one of the first ones off the ship, there is no seating available.

I am at a loss to understand why any cruise line stops here. This port is extremely undesirable. We have been here before and knew better not to venture off on our own unless we went on a ship excursion. So we spent the day on the ship which was nice as most people did get off. However, upon their return there was a lot of the same complaints that they felt threatened and not safe walking around. The guests who took the excursion on the resort did enjoy that trip.

Thank You For Signing Up!

Please Note: To ensure delivery of your free e-letters, please add news@cruisecritic.com to your address book.
We're committed to protecting your privacy and will not rent or sell your e-mail address. By proceeding, you agree to our Privacy Policy and Terms of Use.