Subscribe today
Get Cruise Critic in your inbox
Your Ultimate Cruise Guide

Carnival Liberty Cruise Review by Itsdbfromdb: Ok more bad or average than great


Itsdbfromdb
1 Review
Member Since 2012
0 Posts

Member Rating

Cabin 3.0
Dining 2.0
Embarkation 1.0
Enrichment Activities 3.0
Entertainment 3.0
Family & Children Not Rated
Fitness & Recreation 3.0
Public Rooms 3.0
Rates 1.0
Service 2.0
Shore Excursions 3.0
Value for Money 3.0

Compare Prices on Carnival Liberty Eastern Caribbean Cruises

Ok more bad or average than great

Sail Date: September 2012
Destination: Eastern Caribbean
Embarkation: Miami

This was my first cruise and our honeymoon.. I want to say that first before i start...

Lets start off with the great: the comedians at punchliners comedy club.. Adam hunter, allyn ball and especially happy cole were incredible.. Making fun of carnival was fun as every guest experienced the same headaches let us all laugh together.. Having to clear the club out after each show wait back in line was dumb and frustrating... Move this to a bigger area... Hopefully common sense will prevail and they will learn..

The cleanliness of the ship/shops was impeccable.. Also every interaction we had with the shops crew, guest service and our stewards were great.. The rest of the passengers were very diverse in age and ethnicity

Guys burgers were as good as everyone has stated..

The ports were good, they were reviewed individually later..

The bad/horrible: onboarding was unorganized chaos.. We waited for hours when we were told we could start boarding at More noon.. Seems to be an easier way than waiting to check in waiting to board by zone waiting to get our first of 1458 pictures made waiting to cross the walk to the ship, then waiting along the side of the ship to find our way on board. We didnt start boarding until 230 and the safety meeting was another herding moment that was alot longer than it needed to be..The food was average at best with baby size portions in the dining room. We were dine at your own time in the golden room which we still had to wait.. The wait staff was saddenly uninteractive as well as attentive.. The prime rib was 60% fat and had zero taste.. Had lobster one night and it was good.. The other food seemed preprepared and reheated for the most part and already portioned..

The non dining room meals were average except for the guys burgers.. Lines were painfully too long at every buffet and it seems if the staff was there to help more it might go smoother.. Desserts were average at best, ever other thing we had was bland at best

The hours for the meals were awkward and didnt coincide with port stops very well.. The pizza place was the only place offerring food after 11 pm.. Always a line there too.. No late lunches except for guys burgers was a disappointment.

the director and staff seemed to get more enjoyment out of making fun of people than anything else.. Seemed more like overzealous performers rather than interactive fun.. Karl with a k was more annoying than fun.. The song and dance shows seemed third grade recital yet less rehearsed and talented at best

The drinks were expensive, i wouldnt call it nickel and diming but more of a five and tenning you to death can be costly, fast.. Enjoy the five oz water or lemonade serving unless you want to fork over serious cash to drink..Lastly.. We were on our honeymoon and wish there would have been more for us, people with birthdays got more attention than us.. Not asking for the world but having come from an allinclusive resort where our wedding took place compared to this seemed not 2% as special.. Special spa deals, one free drink heck anything would have been appreciated other than to make sure we get charged for everything would have been nice..

Oh and the disembark part.. Very unorganized like everything else.. Were told everyone had to be out of there room by 830 am.. Wish we would have known that earlier as well..

Overall we made the best of what we were offered.. Bring as much to drink as you can on board and drink cheaply off the boat the best you can.. The offboard carnival owned areas are just as expensive as the drinks are on board so explore plan and make the best of it

Probably will not do carnival again.. It was great seeing different places in so many days but for the money an all inclusive resort was alot better in value for those who enjoy a nice drink or a few on vacation..

Better service, better quality and better prices would make this 100 times better Less


Read more Carnival Liberty cruise reviews >>
Read Cruise Critic's Carnival Liberty Review >>

Cabin review: Carnival Liberty Balcony Verandah 8269

Room was great but smaller than expected, great view from the balcony, quiet most of the time, always kept neat and clean by the stewards

Port and Shore Excursions


Sad stop for us except for governors beach.. The only thing really on grand turk is the area that carnival has built up around the port (just ask any local).. I mean, carnival owns or rents out the "preferred shops" when you get off the boat and is very commericialized.. Seems just like an overpriced extension of an overpriced ship.. We took a cab to governors beach which was quiet and breathtakingly gorgeous.. Seashells, rocks, quiet.. It was amazing.. I would eat and bring drinks with you as the only shop there had very limited everything and was local.. We then went to the historic downtown area which was mainly a few places to eat as big as your onboard cabin and a few shops with hardly anything in them.. It was culture shock, i was expecting and hoping for more, i was saddened the fact that carnival basically built their own community on this island that isnt close to anywhere that would boost or help the local economy as a small trip away from the carnivalized area shows

Half moon cay is carnival owned, so of course drinks are overpriced, food was average and it was crowded.. Excursions on an island the company owns with zero culture there seemed sad to me, nothing to really do you cant do in other places, nothing unique. Beach was crowded to the point of not being fun, also not quiet unless you walked forever to get away from the loud music and games being played.. Getting herded off the ship with zero organization was irritating.. The "bbq" was a continuation of average food.. The water was gorgeous though, sand was nice..

LOVED Old San Juan.. No need to book an excursion unless you want to see the rainforest, they dont tell you a free trolley will take you around the city.. Plan in advance... So the shops in old san juan are great the old fort was a great treat and the views are good too.. Great port just plan and explore, no need to waste the extra money on excusions here in my opinion.
Read 1358 San Juan Reviews

City Tour

(5)
Great excursion.. Started going to megans beach which was absolutely breathtaking.. Stopped for a scenic pic or two along the way.. Drivers were crazy on the windy roads but was fun.. Went to blackbeards castle next.. Was fun, was able to sample alot of rum and see some historic sights while there.. Last was "downtown shopping" which was good, i would advise to explore some other than the pier shops by the ship, we found a store downtown with ship antiques which was amazing.. Caught a ferry ride back on a pirate ship and that was the day.. Overall fun day, gorgeous place

Thank You For Signing Up!

Please Note: To ensure delivery of your free e-letters, please add news@cruisecritic.com to your address book.
We're committed to protecting your privacy and will not rent or sell your e-mail address. By proceeding, you agree to our Privacy Policy and Terms of Use.