Carnival Magic 4

“Love to cruise”
Cruise review of Carnival Magic

Member Since 2012

Overall Member Rating

I love to cruise! We sailed Magic last December and enjoyed every minute.

This cruise was stressful. Too many people cruising with too few people to meet the demands of the people on the cruise. The stewards and others seemed to not be motivated, seemed not to be happy in their jobs, and careless with their tasks. (one person in particular was always leaning on her mop and would swipe it every few minutes then lean again.)

Our cabin steward was exceptionally good. (Ruel was his name)

The food on the buffet was not as good as we had expected. The menu basically never changed. The desserts were awful..of course, us Texans like SWEET. The long lines were like cattle being fed. More serving lines?

The main dining room was wonderful food. However, the attendants were not motivated...too many tables and demands for the number of people to meet those demands. Certainly not fine dining experience. The last cruise experience did not present this More type of service at all.

It is my idea that these people do not feel they are working for their tips and need not hustle. That might be the wrong perception....

There were two nice shows on the trip. If you enjoy trivia stuff, then this cruise was a wonderful time for you. We enjoy the shows. The comedy shows were great and that helped us to be happy. (We would prefer shows each night.) I overlooked the final night show which used passengers on stage..a most unusual (inexpensive?) event.

We will sail Canival again. I wait for improvements of the Magic. Less

Carnival Magic Cruises to the Western Caribbean

Overall Ratings

Sail Date: August 2012
Destination: Western Caribbean
Embarkation: Galveston
Enrichment Activities
Family & Children
Fitness & Recreation
Public Rooms
Shore Excursions
Value for Money

Cabin review: Interior

Our cabin was kept clean..maybe overly clean. Everything was done with a smile and friendly attitude. We were comfortable. No noise problem. We took a nap some afternoons and were able to relax comfortably. We choose an inside cabin because we stay on deck most of the time.

Port and Shore Excursions

Enjoyed the air boat tour and city tour. The tour guide was excellent and made the tour very interesting.

We have visited Cozumel many times, but we went in to a different port this time. Enjoyed walking ashore and just relaxing and watching the crowds.
Read 4536 Cozumel Reviews

First time to visit this port. Took the city tour and enjoyed it very much. The tour guide was great.
Read 2191 Roatan Reviews

Published 08/30/12

Read Cruise Critic's Carnival Magic Review

Carnival Magic Cruises to the Western Caribbean

Share feedback
Thank you!  Cruise Critic values your feedback.
How can we improve this page?