The good: The cabins were lovely. We had two junior suites that were gigantic. The kids had interior cabins across from us, which were small, but they didn't care. Our cabin steward kept everything perfect throughout our stay. We asked for ice the first day and she brought it without having to ask again every day.

We ate as a group with a kids table and an adult table at 7 PM in the Rembrandt dining room 5 nights and were overall pleased with the food, wine and service. I had contemplated pre-ordering a wine package, but I glad I didn't because we were able to find several interesting, reasonable wines to order of the wine list and saved money by comparison. The waiter had no clue about the wine and they never sent over a sommelier, so we picked using our own instincts.

We ate 3 breakfasts at the Windjammer and one dinner. I would recommend avoiding it for dinner and only go as a last resort. It was insanely chaotic and crowded and impossible for a large group to sit together (there is a line of people waiting for it to open each day). Breakfast was also crowded and although there seemed to be waiters, some were filling coffee cups, some just taking plates away. Inconsistent. Read more