This was our first Freestyle Cruise and we thought it was great. The whole family loved wearing shorts at dinner. It was great not having to pack extra clothes and shoes to dress up for dinner. The freedom to eat wherever, whenever was great! It allowed my teenager to just go off with her new friends and have dinner. We eat early so we never had to wait. We even booked some specialty restaurants hours prior. La Cucina is exceptional, especially for such a small cover ($10 if I rammer correctly). The food and service was very good in the main dining rooms as well. My 9 year old son loved the Ice Cream -- I think he had two or three ice cream cones a day.
The staff was great and by mid week everyone knew the washy washy song and the teens loved it. We had to tip our room steward additional $$$ because he so good to us.
We had a great time bowling on the ship, rock climbing, playing basketball, ping pong and bingo. We were always able to find something to do on the Pearl.
We didn't find a lot of time to see the shows because my son was knocked out by 9pm most nights (we run hard in the ports). The Frankie Valli tribute group was very good. We enjoyed it much more than I thought we would.
The ports of call where great! Great Stirrup Cay is a great private Island and they are working on it to make it even better. Climbing Dunns River Falls in Jamaica was the craziest family event we have ever done and we have parasailed and zip lined in Haiti. We really loved Cayman Island -- It was definitely hot, beautiful and easy to get around with good shopping and food. We went to Paradise Beach in Cozumel which was a short taxi ride away with plenty to do and they served you drink and food right at your lounge chairs. The tender process in Great Stirrup and Cayman were smooth.
We found most things to be reasonably priced comparative to other cruises we have been on. The shopping on board was the only maybe negative - not quite as much as we have seen on other ships, but that probably saved me a ton of money. As it turns out there is less shops because of the bowling alley.
We had a picture window room and we found it to be spacious enough for the four us (including a 15 year old teenage girl). Everything was in good working condition and the room didn't have too much wear.
If you are thinking of booking a cruise on the Pearl, you should find it to be clean, fun and containing a friendly staff that strives to serve. You will have a great time.