This was our first cruise so we don't have any other to compare. I booked and then found cruise critic and read some of the bad reviews.
1. The cabins and the ship are very clean.
2. Service is awesome, the staff is everywhere, you don't have to look to far and they all work hard and are friendly.
Cabin 9025, balcony, great views, no loud noises. We loved staying in this cabin. The cabins use space wisely, you can fit lots of items in the nooks, we never lacked for space, we were able to keep everything well organized.