It's hard to find any faults with the cruise. From beginning to end we were treated like royalty. Check in was so easy. The ship is beautiful. Cabins were very nice. Enough room for two without feeling cramped. Food was plentiful and, for the most part, outstanding, although my wife did not really like the sandwich bar. Most evenings we ate in The Restaurant and enjoyed it. The lunch barbecue on the beach and the dinner barbecue on-board were excellent.
We enjoyed the excursions -- canopy adventure on St. Lucia, river tubing in Dominica, and 4x4 island safari an Antigua. The catamaran snorkeling adventure in St. Barths was disappointing. The location where we snorkeled was not good. Very little sea-life to look at.
Nights on-board were rather quiet. Older crowd, us included, that is not really looking for a wild nightlife. The band and the duet were very pleasant to listen to.
The staff from the captain on down did everything possible to make the cruise enjoyable. Only complaint was the mini-bar was not kept full with coke. Had to write a note to our steward (who was excellent) to get the min-bar filled.
BTW, the new policy of free soft drinks and water was very welcome for us.
We are already thinking about a 2013 cruise on Windstar on the Mediterranean.