Subscribe today
Get Cruise Critic in your inbox
Your Ultimate Cruise Guide

Carnival Elation Cruise Review by melwrey: Loved the Elation! Best vacation ever!


melwrey
1 Review
Member Since 2012
15 Posts

Member Rating

Cabin 5.0
Dining 5.0
Embarkation 5.0
Enrichment Activities Not Rated
Entertainment 5.0
Family & Children Not Rated
Fitness & Recreation Not Rated
Public Rooms 5.0
Rates 5.0
Service 5.0
Shore Excursions 5.0
Value for Money 5.0

Compare Prices on Carnival Elation Western Caribbean Cruises

Loved the Elation! Best vacation ever!

Sail Date: March 2012
Destination: Western Caribbean
Embarkation: New Orleans

I had read many bad reviews on here about the Elation being old, unfriendly staff, sorry food, bad entertainment, etc, etc. Those people must have sailed on a different Elation than me. I loved the Elation!
I will start with embarkation. My grown daughter and I drove from Arkansas to New Orleans (about a 6 1/2 hour drive) arriving at Fulton Parking Place about 1:30. I highly recommend this parking garage. The rate is $12.00 a day $4.00 cheaper than the port parking and they shuttle you to the pier of course. Arriving this late there were no lines. We did not check any luggage we only had carry-ons. Security did go through my bag because I had water. I could not believe the water bottles that were confiscated sitting against the wall containing alcohol. There were hundreds of them. I can't believe people really try to get away with this.I found security to be very friendly.
Our room was ready when we got on the ship. Our room was a porthole at the very front of the ship on More Floor 7 Empress which is the floor we had entered on. I was a little leery of being this far forward on the ship but it turned out to be a pleasant surprise. Being at the end of the hall there was no traffic. No doors slamming, no feet going up and down the hall. The steward's closet was beside us but they kept the noise to a minimum and we rarely heard them. We met Seri from Romania our room steward. He was very friendly and always willing to accommodate any need we had. I do have to add that coming into port and dropping the anchors can be loud in the forward rooms but it is only a couple of times and I actually got use to it and enjoyed the sound. lol.
The first time you hear it until you realise what it is can be a little nerve wracking tho. We had Your Time Dining and never had to wait more than 5 minutes for a table even when we showed up during main dining hours. The hostess, maitre'd, wait staff were all very friendly and knew our names from the first night even tho we did not sit at the same table every meal. We took all our meals in the dining room. I much prefer the slow pace of this to the business of the buffet on the lido deck. This is what I cruise for to be waited on! The food was always good and they were more than willing to bring you something else if they thought you did not like what you had been served. One of our favorite waiters was Anthony from the Philippines. At one of the meals there was a mix up and two ladies never received their desserts so they left. You could tell he took pride in his job and this was very upsetting to him. I felt so bad for him.
We did the Chef's Table one evening and I can not rave enough about this. It is an extra expense for it but well worth it and more. Turning out thousands of meals at a time they don't get to show off their expertise as much. At the Chef's Table they really shine. I was blown away by the quality (and quantity) of the food. Executive Chef Govind Bahal (India) and staff were beyond extraordinary. It is a seven course meal not counting the most mouth watering appetizers, champagne, and wine. You also get a tour of the galley and shown how they make that wonderful chocolate melting cake. This is an experience out of this world. I highly recommend every one enjoy this at least once. I do say you might no want to take small children. It is a long night. We started with the tour of the galley at 6:30 and finished up with the meal at about 9:30. Also most of the foods are not going to be recognisable to kids, they may balk at trying it. Just my thoughts on that. I have heard of kids having melt downs through these long dinners.
The entertainment I found to be top notch also. Our cruise director Gary and his assistant Nick were hysterical. Gary is from England and Nick from Dallas. They play off each other wonderfully with this. Ryan and Rachel are part of the entertainment staff and we really enjoyed them as well. These people are very good at what they do. I thought all the shows were really good and well done. The new Legends show was outstanding!
Now finishing up my thoughts on the ship. I found the Elation well maintained.They were constantly cleaning and doing maintenance. I loved her understated colors and thought she was beautiful. I have sailed on the Conquest also which is a much larger ship. I have to say I prefer the smaller class of the Elation. I know that is just a personal preference and everyone has their own opinion on that. It was day 5 of a 7 day cruise before I finally figured out the lay of the Conquest. I stayed confused all the time. Of course it was my first cruise and I didn't understand the difference with the forward and aft elevators. I knew the lay out of the Elation by the end of embarkation day. For first time cruisers I would recommend the smaller class of ships. The larger ones can be very overwhelming to start with. Once again just my opinion. Loved the Elation and look forward to sailing her again. Less


Read more Carnival Elation cruise reviews >>
Read Cruise Critic's Carnival Elation Review >>

Cabin review: Carnival Elation Interior Empress E1

Very quiet location, at the end of the hall so there is no foot traffic and slamming of doors. Coming into port and lowering of anchors can get noisy. I think there is some extra footage on these very forward cabins. They are quite roomy with ample closet space and large bathroom. This cabin is next to steward closet but they worked hard at keeping the noise to a minimum and we rarely heard them. Would book this room again.

Port and Shore Excursions


Culinary Tour

(5.5)
Highly recommend this one if you are a food junkie. Master Chef Luis and his staff are not only wonderful instructors and talented at their profession but highly entertaining as well. The food is delicious and there is also an open bar. The cooking class in it self is outstanding. There was one disappointment to the excursion. The class is held at the Playa Mia resort and you have time after the class to go out and enjoy the beach. My daughter had looked forward to snorkeling here. The catamarans are coming in and out and water is very choppy here. Where the snorkeling area is the beach drops off sharply with jagged coral. My daughter came out with bloody knees after only 5 minutes. Not the best place for snorkeling.

As far as I am concerned this port gets a bad rap. I enjoyed the small town of Progreso. I do say there is not much to do here except the Mayan ruins. We took the $3.00 tour bus through town which last about 20 minutes. There are cheap massages to be had. My daughter and I paid $20.00 for 45 minutes and received great massages. This was right on the block where we got off the tour bus. I did notice the massages got cheaper the closer you got to the beach. We had a little more privacy where we got ours done and not laid out on the beach half naked. If that doesn't bother you more power to you tho and save some more bucks. I enjoyed my privacy. I had plenty of ones for tips but had forgotten to break my hundreds for smaller bills before going into port. These places do not keep change. I very warily handed my large bill to my masseuse to go get change. It took her only about 5 minutes to come back but it seemed like an hour wondering if she had ran off with that hundred. I hate to think that way but it does happen. Thankfully she returned with all my change and I happily tipped her. Reminder: break large bills before going into port. Buddy's restaurant had been highly recommended I have to say I was a little disappointed. They had been touted for their 2 for $5.00 margaritas. I love a good margarita, these not so much. They came in 8 ounce glasses with about 6 ounces of tequila and 2 of mix and only about 2 ice cubes. Warm mostly straight tequila is not my idea of a good margarita. But hey if you want to get drunk this is the place to do it. They also give free tequila shots out quite generously. They allow the street vendors to come in and solicit from table to table. A few might be okay but this was a constant stream of saying "no thank you, no thank you" It was hard to get your meal eaten. The food was not great but not bad. The beach was clean and beautiful and I felt very safe in the little town. They actually have a Wal-Mart there they are very proud of. lol
Read 284 Progreso Reviews

Thank You For Signing Up!

Please Note: To ensure delivery of your free e-letters, please add news@cruisecritic.com to your address book.
We're committed to protecting your privacy and will not rent or sell your e-mail address. By proceeding, you agree to our Privacy Policy and Terms of Use.