Top-Rated Cruise Line Private Island Destinations

The top-rated destinations in cruise line private islands chosen by cruisers. All rankings are based on member review ratings for cruises taken in 2015.
1
Photo by Cruise Critic member Horizons1983
Castaway Cay
“This island is Paradise. My husband kept saying that he couldn't believe a place so gorgeous and clean and colorful actually exists. The sand was powder soft and white. The water turquoise. The foliage was bright and healthy. It was as close to Heaven-on-Earth as it gets.” - christinas
2016 Cruisers’ Choice
1 of 5
Cruise Line Private Island Destinations
4
Photo by Cruise Critic member jmelo
Labadee
“AMAZING... Tons of adventurous stuff to do. And the beaches are breathtaking. Whether you like ocean waves or a gentle bay with the cruise ship visible in the distance, this place is a gem.” - lpslot
2016 Cruisers’ Choice
4 of 5
Cruise Line Private Island Destinations
5
Photo by Cruise Critic member kdotson4
CocoCay
“Beautiful island. Took our snorkeling gear and had a blast. Great barbecue lunch by the ship. Don't miss the ribs... Nice island to walk around and see all the little lizards.” - karen&roy
2016 Cruisers’ Choice
5 of 5
Cruise Line Private Island Destinations
Share feedback
Thank you!  Cruise Critic values your feedback.
How can we improve this page?