Carnival New York (Manhattan) Cruise Reviews

Filter reviews by:
Your selections (clear selections):
Carnival x
New York (Manhattan) x
Carnival Cruise Line
Carnival Cruise Line
Cruise Critic Overview
  • Cruises are for families and fun-lovers of all ages
  • "Fun Ships" offer great value-for-money
  • The world's largest cruise line -- big ships with panache
  • Read full overview >>

1,223 Carnival New York (Manhattan) Cruise Reviews

Cruiser rating
Excellent
568
Very Good
295
Average
205
Poor
83
Terrible
40
See reviews for
Family Cruises
Family Cruises
314
Romantic Cruises
Romantic Cruises
70
First-Time Cruisers
First-Time Cruisers
51
Senior Cruises
Senior Cruises
35
Rating Summary
Dining
Public Rooms
Cabin
Entertainment
Value for Money
Service
boisegirl111
Member Since 2016
1 review
2 forum posts
0 helpful votes
Sailed three weeks ago
i chose carnival cruises because we have never sailed with them before.the food was delish,the entertainment standard,shore excursions expensive as usual,our cabin was an inside but was fine because you don't spend a lot of time in it.i ... Read more
Inspirn
Member Since 2010
3 reviews
0 forum posts
1 helpful vote
I am an avid reader of other people's cruise reviews prior to going on a cruise. Therefore I try to return the favor at the conclusion of my cruise. It is not so much a review as it is my cruise memoir. Here goes. My last cruise was ... Read more
cruising59
Member Since 2016
1 review
0 forum posts
0 helpful votes
Sailed four weeks ago
This was our first cruise with Carnival so we weren't sure what to expect. Carnival was a blast! We have sailed on other cruise lines but we have never had as many activities as Carnival provided. Even though Carnival Sunshine is ... Read more
Deedee40
Member Since 2016
1 review
0 forum posts
1 helpful vote
Sailed four weeks ago
We choose the cruise because we never been to carnival before did norweign twice,, I'll say average because it was only two nights of entertainment meaning the shows, they were amazing thou but norweign gem had a show every night,,,,the ... Read more
Sail Happy
Member Since 2005
1 review
116 forum posts
10 helpful votes
Sailed four weeks ago
My cruise on the Sunshine was my 23rd with Carnival and by far the worst. I can summarize this review by saying "What a difference a year makes." I was on the Carnival Splendor last year and have no complaints about that cruise. ... Read more

Compare Prices on Carnival Cruises

kcofone
Member Since 2016
1 review
0 forum posts
6 helpful votes
Sailed four weeks ago
only chose this cruise because wife's family booked and invited us to go along. 8 day cruise out of manhattan to San Juan, St thomas, and Grand Turk. Pros, Staff was , for the most part, friendly and attentive . Ship looked ... Read more
phillyf
Member Since 2003
2 reviews
748 forum posts
5 helpful votes
Sailed four weeks ago
We wanted to cruise out of NY for the July 4th weekend and decided to give Carnival another try. This was our 15th cruise, 10 on NCL, 4 Carnival and 1 Celebrity. My wife, brother in law and I wanted some much needed R&R. My wife and I ... Read more
UsedtoBeKati
Member Since 2016
1 review
10 forum posts
13 helpful votes
Considerations: • We are a family of three in our 30’s with a 3 year old • We didn’t eat in the MDR • We didn’t go to any of the shows or comedy acts, so I can’t comment on the space or ... Read more
Barb1954
Member Since 2010
3 reviews
17 forum posts
13 helpful votes
Sailed June 2016
Just got off of a 4-day cruise from New York to St. Johns. When I got on the ship (it was my first time on Sunshine) I thought how beautiful it looked and how clean – very understated, but nice. Unfortunately, this was not my ... Read more
sharahulda
Member Since 2016
1 review
0 forum posts
19 helpful votes
Sailed June 2016
We saw whales on the way out to sea this cruise, and that should of been an omen. THAR SHE BLOWS, becase this cruise kept on blowing. Well, actually it started before that with our arrival at the teminal when everyone was told, as rhey ... Read more

Compare Prices on Carnival Cruises

seek1
Member Since 2015
2 reviews
1 forum post
13 helpful votes
This was not my first cruise, however, it was my first and last with Carnival. The only reason we booked this cruise was because we live in NJ and it sailed from Manhattan. The food in the lido buffet was pathetic. Nothing in the buffet ... Read more
Helpful? Thank seek1
sshs
Member Since 2011
5 reviews
98 forum posts
5 helpful votes
I would have liked to give it a 3 (average), but of the nearly 40 cruises we've been on, it was definitely in the bottom 10%, For me, the crowded nature of the ship - a result of Carnival adding cabins and reducing the public space when ... Read more
Helpful? Thank sshs
Long neck 567
Member Since 2016
1 review
0 forum posts
6 helpful votes
Cruised Carnival in past.always a great experience. This cruise was the worst ever. Staff not friendly, food service awful, dining room waiters didn't even pour our water and were so frazzled forgot stuff. Food either undercooked or ... Read more
Casino Player
Member Since 2004
11 reviews
3,599 forum posts
2 helpful votes
Sailed June 2016
We chose this cruise because it was on a ship we haven't been on before and it was going to Canada. Later in the year we are going to the Caribbean. Therefore, we were not interested in going there now. Also, this is our ninth time to ... Read more
NiceBob7
Member Since 2015
3 reviews
0 forum posts
10 helpful votes
I been on a couple cruises with Carnival to Canada already. Sunshine is a refurnished smaller ship than the four other Carnival ships I been on.. They added more rooms took away other stuff. But did not realized the dining and Lido Buffet ... Read more

Compare Prices on Carnival Cruises

MostlyLegal
Member Since 2012
7 reviews
0 forum posts
0 helpful votes
Sailed June 2016
This cruise was chosen for a family reunion; 15 family members set sail out of New York for a short cruise to Canada. The New York sail away was wonderful – past lower Manhattan, the Freedom Tower, Ellis Island and the Statue of ... Read more
Longstockingpippi1
Member Since 2016
1 review
14 forum posts
3 helpful votes
It was the first cruise for my daughter and I. She is 31, severely handicapped and uses a wheelchair outside of the house. I wanted to try a different sort of vacation for us since Disney and Universal (definitely NOT Universal) are too ... Read more
Goldy RN
Member Since 2016
1 review
0 forum posts
1 helpful vote
First cruise-- was absolutely DE-lighted!!! Carnival staff all were helpful, friendly, and very accommodating. Cabin with two twin beds, 2nd deck aft, was more than ample with closet & drawer space aplenty. Bathroom certainly ... Read more
Reesa123
Member Since 2010
1 review
40 forum posts
10 helpful votes
Like others I was a little stressed after reading some of these reviews but have to say my experience was excellent. It was a 4 day cruise to St. John/Canada. I have been to that port several times before so just got off the boat to shop ... Read more
Blondy-grl
Member Since 2016
1 review
0 forum posts
17 helpful votes
First Carnival cruise! We didn't want to fly to go to a port so we drove from VA to NY. I have been on Royal Caribbean cruise ships before so this was a first carnival experience for my husband and I. We were celebrating our 15th wedding ... Read more

Compare Prices on Carnival Cruises

alaskalu0720
Member Since 2015
1 review
0 forum posts
3 helpful votes
This was by far the worst cruise I have ever taken. It started off bad and ended bad. First of all, I just getting to the ship on October 4th was a hassle. Months and weeks before the cruise, Carnival stated in their emails to plan on ... Read more
NiceBob7
Member Since 2015
3 reviews
0 forum posts
0 helpful votes
Sailed October 2015
This was our second cruise on the Splendor this year we when on the vehicle back in August to the Carb (see my review on that) Getting there was a horror as NYC had bike race outside closing down the West Side Highway and took us extra ... Read more
potters2308
Member Since 2015
1 review
0 forum posts
1 helpful vote
Hopefully our telling this critic review will be helpful to others .. We are just getting back from our trip on Carnival Splendor 7 days from NY to Canada/New England date of our trip 10/04/15 to 10/11/15 .. We booked spa cabin ... Read more
queenoftwdw
Member Since 2010
2 reviews
3 forum posts
2 helpful votes
Overall the cruise was wonderful---I have always enjoyed reading all the reviews and after 27 Carnival cruises i guess it's time to start speaking up!!! Went on the Splendor 10/4 Canada cruise The ship Splendor is one of those ..you ... Read more
Clamshell
Member Since 2004
1 review
105 forum posts
0 helpful votes
The Splendor cruise ranked right down near the bottom of my nearly 40 cruises. I'll not blame Carnival for the 'rocking and rolling' caused by weather, they have no control over that. The staterooms were kept clean by the overly ... Read more

Compare Prices on Carnival Cruises

Sponsored links

Sponsored links

Share feedback
Thank you!  Cruise Critic values your feedback.
How can we improve this page?

Thank You For Signing Up!

Please Note: To ensure delivery of your free e-letters, please add news@cruisecritic.com to your address book.
We're committed to protecting your privacy and will not rent or sell your e-mail address. By proceeding, you agree to our Privacy Policy and Terms of Use.