Subscribe today
Get Cruise Critic in your inbox

Carnival Magic Cabin Reviews - Balcony

Home > Carnival Ship Reviews > Carnival Magic Reviews > Carnival Magic Cabin Reviews
Balcony Cabins 19 Reviews
Balcony Stateroom Take pleasure in the view and comfort in the space.
Balcony (8C)
Balcony (8C)

Cabin Rating

Very quiet room. No noise from the Promenade Deck below, far enough away from the elevated hot tub to still be private. Great location, close to the atrium elevators but far enough away to avoid atrium noise. Once in awhile could hear brats running in corridor but not enough a problem to be an issue. No detectable noise from above or below. Almost exactly the same as last year's Cove Balcony on Carnival Dream, similar size balcony - two chairs (one reclined) and small cocktail table. Queen size bed, splitable to two twins, one couch convertible to a bed - max capacity 3. Typical size bathroom with one sink, smallish shower stall that flooded the bathroom, resulted in new towels every day. Typical toilet. One outlet in bathroom - near ceiling above mirror. Ample storage with 3 closets, two with hanging rods one with shelves. Fridge fully stocked (can be emptied once in international waters). Plenty of room under queen bed for two large suit cases and two rolling carry on. Room safe in cabinet under in room vanity with drawers, top drawer has hair dryer. Be advised almost every deck has self service laundry facility.

 Read entire member review.
6410 6th floor balcony overlooks the 5th floor lanai. No privacy. Otherwise the room was fine.  Read entire member review.
Great location except for sailing away in Galveston. We were on the wrong side! Lots of storage space. Beds are high enough for big suitcases to fit under them! Love the lighting options.  Read entire member review.
It was Magic!!!!!! by Lunatic_mic
This balconey cabin is located in just the right spot. It is right next to elevators, and above the casino. Also near the stewards room with the ice machine in it, making us one of the first ones to get service. We did not have any noise issues.  Read entire member review.
Nice cabin, far enough away from elevators and other public areas to be quiet.  Read entire member review.
Great Fall Cruise! by F18Pilot

Cabin was port side, foward. We had connecting room with 8240. Love the location! Right below Serenity, Spa and waterslides. No noise above or below. Convenient to forward elevators and stairs, but not right next to them. We had the steward open the balcony door as well and enjoyed our connecting decks!

 Read entire member review.
Bad reviews..... by JMcgo1979
Great location to the elevator and had a great view. If you like looking at the other ships docked, chose something on the left hand side of the ship.  Read entire member review.
Six Magic Nights. by Sirwinston
Good Location. Very Quiet. Lots of closet space. Nice balcony that was sunny enough to lounge on on the last sea day. Only had to walk up two flight of stairs to get to lido and all the fun.  Read entire member review.
This is the first time on a cruise that I could hear the people next door slamming their door to balcony - and they slammed it over and over and over again! You could also hear a lot of noise on the decks when people moved their chair or table around. The weather was so nice we were all outside enjoying it so that may have contributed to all the noise on the decks. The room itself was pretty standard. There was enough room in the shelves & drawers for 2 women's clothing. The bathroom had lots of shelves which was very nice.  Read entire member review.
Wonderful Magic! by buzzsmom
We enjoyed our cabin. It was across from the crew pantry so you'd hear them scooping ice if you slept in past 8 (which we didn't do!) Our steward was wonderful. Everything was clean and new. The bed was extremely comfortable.  Read entire member review.

I recently got back from a Christmas cruise on Carnival Magic. I stayed in Balcony cabin 8434, which was advertised as an 'extended balcony' with a surcharge, but it is actually a standard-size balcony (this issue never got corrected when brought to the attention of 'Customer Service'- they provided me an e-mail to send in my 'complaint'). I would not recommend the location, aft, on this ship- the temperature became unbearable, about 84 degrees (F) in my cabin, which the A/C. It felt like a swamp, but the front of the ship (forward) was ice-cold.
My cabin, though no fault of the staff, was destroyed. There appeared to be mold growing on the headboard, and the dresser had a sticky substance coating the bottom of it. The robes had someone's name written on both of them, in pen, which made it very unappealing to wear. The ice bucket was missing, and so were the glasses. The bathroom was extremely limited, with the mirror having some kind of acid burn/crack on it. Compared to my first cruise with a few freebies, this stateroom included a bar of soap and a roll of toilet paper that had about 10 squares left on it.

 Read entire member review.
We had a balcony cabin towards the back of the ship on deck 8. It was great our steward, Rosie, was amazing. She had the room cleaned super fast each morning and we barely saw here.  Read entire member review.

We love having a balcony to sit out, read and relax, even when in port, so I opted for 8462, port side, rear, which had an extended balcony. We knew that there was no couch because of the unusual layout, but we had no idea how tiny the room was. In fact it was so tiny that you could not open the bathroom door more than halfway because of it hitting the bed! There was a small dining room sized chair, the bed, the dressing table area, and a long, narrow, useless hallway. The balcony was longer than usual, but the chairs were so sooty that we had to wipe them off before we could sit down. On two of the five days, we were told that the balcony would be hosed down and cleaned, but no one seemed to know when. We ended up having to rush inside both days when they started hosing the balconies above us. Later on there were wet cigarette butts all over our balcony [we do not smoke] and they were still there the day we left. Also the balconies were merely hosed off, but never dried afterwards. Not much point having a larger balcony if you cannot use it.
Another issue with the room was that the water in the bathroom never got very hot, and we timed how long it took to get any hot water to the basin - over 2 1/2 minutes before it got warm. When we told our cabin steward, he sighed and said, "Yes, I'll tell them again about the hot water." It seems that it is an ongoing problem with this room.

 Read entire member review.
We had to put our lifejackets under the bed to fit clothes for 12 days for a family of 4 in the closets.  Read entire member review.
Very good location. Close to the Spa but far enough away for more privacy. Neighbors could be slightly heard, but overall pretty quiet. Balcony was nice. Not very large but had room for 2 chairs and table. Cabin was spacious and very clean. Good storage. Could hear everyone in the hallway  Read entire member review.
Great bathroom shower (temp. curtains and shelves) Balcony over a hot tub (noise and no privacy)  Read entire member review.
These cabins were rated but not individually reviewed; read the full cruise review for opinions on cabins and more.
Cabin Rating
Carnival Magic Decks
Carnival Magic Riviera Deck
Carnival Magic Main Deck
Carnival Magic Lobby Deck
Carnival Magic Atlantic Deck
Carnival Magic Promenade Deck
Carnival Magic Upper Deck
Carnival Magic Empress Deck
Carnival Magic Verandah Deck
Carnival Magic Vista Deck
Carnival Magic Lido Deck
Carnival Magic Panorama Deck
Carnival Magic Spa Deck
Carnival Magic Sun Deck
Carnival Magic Sky Deck
About UsAdvertisingEditorial DisclaimerPress
PrivacySite MapStoreSubscribe

Thank You For Signing Up!

Please Note: To ensure delivery of your free e-letters, please add to your address book.

We're committed to protecting your privacy and will not rent or sell your e-mail address. By proceeding, you agree to our Privacy Policy and Terms of Use.