Overboard State of Mind

Editor's note: This story is from the Cruise Critic Archives. Content was up to date at time of publication.

"At the Captain's Table" is Cruise Critic's original series of stories penned by Joyce Gleeson-Adamidis. Joyce knows the ins and outs of life onboard -- both as a cruise ship staff member and as the wife of Celebrity Cruises' venerable Captain Adamidis -- and offers a behind-the-scenes perspective on issues facing cruisers and the cruise industry.

Overboard State of Mind

It is hard to imagine how a survivor feels after going overboard, and after recent incidents this year -- one passenger who fell from Carnival Glory and a couple who toppled off Grand Princess -- you're not alone in wondering what it's like and how it happens. There are those who intentionally end their pain, and there are those who are reckless, careless and silly in their behavior never believing they can fall overboard. However, when it does happen, what is involved and how does the crew feel when dealing with such an emergency?

The number one question asked is, "How in the world does someone fall overboard?" There are four answers: alcohol/drugs; suicide; doing something foolhardy; or genuinely by accident. Going overboard is an act that cannot be predicted nor can it be stopped once in progress.

The whole ship is put in jeopardy when such an event happens. Several life ring buoys must be thrown to offer the person at risk a floating device, hoping the victim can reach one if he has not already been injured or pulled under the ship.

The vessel must turn back, find position, stop engines and lower lifeboat rescue squads. A request is sent to other ships within a 30-nautical-mile radius to aid in search and rescue. The Coast Guard might be called to use a low flying helicopter or plane to scan the waters. Both crew and passengers are asked to keep lookout in hopes of spotting a tiny speck bobbing in the sea waters.

There is no preset time limit to search. The Captain uses his discretion and all the tools available to him. As long as there is hope, the search continues. Whether it involves a cruise ship, military ship, fishing boat or even an immigrant journey craft, there is an informative read on the laws referring to SAR (Search and Rescue) and SOLAS (The Safety of Life at Sea) at: www.imo.org.

I asked crewmembers on Princess, Royal Caribbean, Celebrity, Crystal and Cunard for their feelings about these incidents. Putting it bluntly, it puts a damper on what should be, for passengers, a fun-filled and supposedly stress-free vacation -- no matter how it turns out. And it's no fun for crewmembers, either. If a person survives, the atmosphere is uplifted and there is cause for celebration. But sometimes the news is heartbreaking. A butler told me that when he has experienced a life overboard, he feels sick inside, dizzy and has to really push to work as he tries to figure out how anyone could take their life. A waiter remembers those at his table drinking heavily; when one later fell over, he felt that he should have told them they were drinking too much and be careful. He did not feel it was his fault, as they had been drinking prior to dinner, but will always feel hollow inside as he didn't try to stop them. Crew has to come to terms with these episodes and keep their services moving forward.

In 1992, we were on board the Britanis when an 18-year-old passenger went overboard. Worse, he was physically in the captain's hands at the time. The captain had noticed he was acting strangely and as he grabbed hold of the young man's arms, just to talk with him, the passenger pulled away, ran out the door and just leapt over the railing. The captain yelled, "Man overboard, turn starboard," and the ship was turning as the jumper hit water. After lifeboats were lowered a search began, and a nearby vessel from Norwegian Cruise Line fortunately found him with a spotlight and took him aboard. He was lucky by all accounts: A somewhat calm sea, clear skies and a full moon greatly improved his chances of being rescued. And his reason was, of course, one of the four I have mentioned; he'd taken drugs and alcohol that made him hallucinate that the ship was in a mutiny situation.

In 1999, onboard Celebrity Millennium during our New Year's Eve celebrations, a crewmember advised a friend that his personal situation was too much for him. Dressed in black and handing his wallet to him, he then disappeared. During a thorough ship search, it was presumed he jumped. The ship began search and rescue procedures. The captain refused to give up without finding him. We spent every sunlit hour, assisted by a Coast Guard plane, searching. He was never found.

We were all hurt; we asked ourselves -- how did we miss the signs? It took months to get over not just the hurt but also the anger; he had put his family and the crew in turmoil, not to mention the cost of changing the itinerary and the effect on the passengers' emotions during their vacations.

The price paid by the crew and ship is nothing compared to one who has lost his life, for sure. But when hanky panky has played a role, then it is a different matter. One ex-cruise director stated, "To accidentally fall overboard is usually due to alcohol and then the press enters, putting the cruise industry in the cross hairs ... turning it into bad publicity for us as a whole."

It's not always that way, though. A friend who works as a doctor onboard ships tells me he's experienced seven instances in which passengers have gone overboard. And get this: None of them were alcohol or drug related! One fell off when he lost balance standing on a table while the ship was full speed ahead -- he survived. Two separate incidents occurred while people were taking pictures on the pier, backed off and fell between the ship and the pier (perhaps the term should be "overpier"); both survived, amazingly, without being squashed. Another was a staged event for personal gain and the last two were successful suicides.

"As you can see it isn't always fun," says a ship's captain. "There is something about ships that sometimes causes people to check their brains at the pier -- and they reclaim them only after they disembark." Let me just put it this way: Falling overboard is dangerous and unacceptable whatever the reason. Lives can be lost, money is needlessly squandered, others are at risk, stress levels sharply increase, cruise delays result and costly fuel is burned up.

Of course we all remember the very recent circumstance of passengers who went overboard -- it occurred on Princess Cruises' Grand Princess, and the young, 20-something couple survived.

A friend onboard during that cruise told me that he was "baffled as to how anyone can be out in the water four-plus hours and survive without a life jacket. Looking out into the eerie ... dark waters, I cannot even imagine what must go through one's head as your ship is sailing away from you and there is nothing but water. These are two very fortunate people who, I hope, can realize the magnitude of what happened and will learn just how meaningful the rest of their lives can be."

You May Also Like:

Share feedback
Thank you!  Cruise Critic values your feedback.
How can we improve this page?